By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Microsoft - Fable 2 is going to be the best RPG of 2008. Easily.

shio said:

Fable 2 better than Bioware's Dragon Age or Mass Effect PC? I highly doubt it. The first Fable was barely decent and Molineux hasn't developed a great game in ages.

Torillian said:
@Dogweed
I think it's the only one that could compete with critics, but I don't think that that means it's a shoe in to be the best RPG of 2008. Many RPG fans don't tout Mass Effect as the best RPG of 2007, that honor goes to Persona 3. Could be just the circles I travel in (metaphorically....on the internet), but that's the general consensus I see. What this means is that any RPG, whether it's budget be huge or no, could be the best RPG of 2008. That goes for all consoles too, doesn't mean I'm writing off the 360 as getting the best RPG, I just don't think it's as easy a call as you're making it out to be.

Many RPG fans don't tout Mass Effect or Persona 3 as the best RPG of 2007, that honor goes to The Witcher. If you are an RPG fan, buy The Witcher and see what a great RPG is.


 Hello

 I was about to say the same thing Shio, except for the people who dont have any knowledge of pc games, the best rpg of 2007 was "the witcher".

Bye. 



Zones : I still don't understand all the love for Blizzard, what was the last game they developed worth playing?
Around the Network

It'll be awesome, but the I doubt the sales will be



Hi, i'm solojohlo and i'm pretty fucking awesome

Playing through Fable 1, I was VERY unimpressed, so I find it hard to believe that this one will be any better. But I have to, since it's basically in the same boat as Killzone 2. The first one sucked, so you want to believe the second one will, but I've been saying that maybe Guerilla learned their lesson, so maybe Peter Molyneux learned his also. Maybe this game will be full of win.



DMeisterJ said:
Playing through Fable 1, I was VERY unimpressed, so I find it hard to believe that this one will be any better. But I have to, since it's basically in the same boat as Killzone 2. The first one sucked, so you want to believe the second one will, but I've been saying that maybe Guerilla learned their lesson, so maybe Peter Molyneux learned his also. Maybe this game will be full of win.


Metacritic:

Fable 85

Killzone 70

 

Fable's was considerably marked down due to "not meeting the hype."

Sorry DMeister but I fail to see the comparison. 



starcraft - Playing Games = FUN, Talking about Games = SERIOUS

The first Fable sucked hard. Why Fable 2 is supposed to be the best 2008 RPG? For me it smells like Killzone 2. The first game was all hype and turned out being mediocre.

Edit: Damn you DMeister J. Do not steal my killzone 2 argument.



Satan said:

"You are for ever angry, all you care about is intelligence, but I repeat again that I would give away all this superstellar life, all the ranks and honours, simply to be transformed into the soul of a merchant's wife weighing eighteen stone and set candles at God's shrine."

Around the Network

I am definitely looking forward to Fable II. Fable was my favorite RPG on the original xbox.

I do have some concerns though...the idea of replacing a map with a dog to guide you around seems really corny.

And I don't like the idea of "one" button combat.

But, hopefully my concerns are unwarranted and the game will be great.

But please be a 20+ hour RPG...anything shorter is too short for an RPG.



PSN ID: Sorrow880

Gamertag: Sorrow80

Wii #: 8132 1076 3416 7450

As to why I said Fable could of been a Zelda-Killer in my eyes:

Fable, like Zelda, has a great easy-to-get combat mechanism. Both are over-the-head adventure games with RPG elements - Zelda has HP in the form of hearts, and so on. Fable is more RPG than Zelda, but I feel that Fable is the RPG simplified (as Zelda is the casual RPG perfected). Thats merely the way I viewed them.


Having said that, Fable wasn't nearly as good as what I hoped, because the length of the game was poor (for what it could of been), and the story was very weak. It's a bad game when you have non-gaming friends doing Fable Speedruns on their second playthrough.

Will Fable 2 sell well? Yes. It's going to sell very well. Go look at the "top 5" list - Mass Effect was the last game to have that high of dominance, and we know how that went. Fallout 3, on the X360, should sell atleast 2m copies worldwide (if not more), and Fable 2 is beating it by about 1.5:1 at the moment.

I don't "get" the Fable hype, as Fable was the biggest letdown of last-gen for me. F2 looks promising, and I will GLADLY agree that it looks very promising. But after failing on F1...I won't build anticipation for it. I'd say, of the 9 RPGs coming out this year, it *might* be #5 on a good day.



Back from the dead, I'm afraid.

Fable one was let down by the fact that the title was hyped beyond it's capacity to deliver. In the end game's only real let-down was it's length.

For Fable 2, we are promised that the world is bigger, and that the game will be longer.



starcraft - Playing Games = FUN, Talking about Games = SERIOUS

starcraft said:
Fable one was let down by the fact that the title was hyped beyond it's capacity to deliver. In the end game's only real let-down was it's length.

For Fable 2, we are promised that the world is bigger, and that the game will be longer.


No, Fable was a terribly disappointing RPG. It was too short, too easy, weak story and characters, and the 'aging' feature(which was supposed to be Fable's main hook) was a gimmick and ended up hurting the immersion.

It's not enough to promise, Molineux also had made promises on the first one and when the game came it did not hold up to them.



Fable 1 wasn't a letdown at all for me, they hyped it and promised it to no end true, but it was still a great game in my opinion with an amazing style :P Fable 2 is going to be amazing, possibly the greatest WRPG I've ever played. As long as they're not bogged down with technical difficulties ala Mass Effect, this could take the slot from ME and Oblivion :P



From 0 to KICKASS in .stupid seconds.