By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - General Discussion - Mafia Round 73 Game Thread - Is that you, Archer?

Can we get a mod to check if zero has an alternative account



Around the Network

Keep it simple stupid.
Prof is town, that's how he knows zero is lying.
(Man, what an idiot)



Mr.P trusts me over you because your points are weak. All you accusations are full of conjecture, and not good conjecture, but complicated scenarios involving third party survivors, godfathers, and WIFOM. It's basically the same accusations that zero had against me.

When I was arguing with zero, it was for several reasons, and his major stance against me was because he was so keen about his cop status he wouldn't listen to any reason other than his own. His weird conjecture came about because he was so firmly planted in his motivation. He argued math because his role made his decision biased, thinking that no lynches would get him more time to cop. His conjecture that I was trying to get him lynched because I was mafia was because he believed himself to be incredibly important to town's victory, and therefore questioning him was scummy. While he's also a complete idiot for thinking these things without considering the alternatives, it's easy to see his train of thought behind it. A simple mind thinking simple things.

With you, I don't see any specific reasoning behind it. You accept zero without hesitation. You create these wild theories about my potential roles, even calling me a godfather for some reason. You call me a godfather, despite the fact that you completely trust zero, the cop, who just called me guilty. Those two ideas cannot coexist. I cannot both be a godfather, and have zero's words be accurate. It's hypocrisy. It then takes you some time to realize this, and you change the "evidence" to fit your conclusion again. This time, I'm a third party who wins with mafia. Ah, no hypocrisy there. Much stronger argument. It's just too bad that it still doesn't suit me to win with mafia when everything I've done today has been to help town. My no lynch plan is to give zero another scan and remove a suspect. It additionally solved the "who is telling the truth between prof and zero" question.
You are running into hypocritical statements left and right.

That is why you are not trusted by either me, or mr.P. It has nothing to do with anything I write. It's so obvious to anyone reading. You additionally were the only one who hopped on my "let's go after the cop" trap yesterday, when in fact, I expected mr.p to be the one.

I'm about 95% certain that you're the mafia. The other 5% is that the mafia is zero. Again, my reasoning being that I still think cop is OP, and that he came in here and called me guilty and then disappeared. So, I know he's lying. I know he's OP, and the disappearance is very scummy because in my head, his play was to say that, go on an alt account, watch mrp and spurge vote me, and then log in and hammer. That is my paranoid thinking.

However, there could be reasons for those things. Perhaps mafia has a disinformation role, which would solve the OP cop problem. Perhaps zero's computer or cell broke or something happened to keep him away for so long, which would solve the disappearance problem.
In contrast, there isn't much available in terms of explaining why you're acting weird.



The very post where I suspected you, I said I suspected zero, and basically said everything you just did already.

Despite being here alone this whole time, you haven't even bothered to re-read, so I'll repeat myself. I suspected that zero didn't vote trucks because he wanted to use trucks as a sacrifice to make his cop claim seem real. He didn't vote for one of the two people that he himself determined to be the either/or vote on day 1. To paraphrase, he said, "so it's between mrP and trucks. And then he votes xander.

Again, I don't trust zero. I've said so from the beginning of today. It's also why mrP hasn't voted for you yet, (I assume), because like me he also doesn't trust zero who could potentially show up and hammer.

And again, I'm actually the doc. Lynching me today ends the game immediately.
My decision today is either going to be lynching you or no lynch, because like I said earlier, tonight:
If I die, you know zero is mafia
If zero dies, you know I'm mafia
If spurge dies, we know zero is mafia (at least, I do)
If MrP dies, it doesn't solve anything, so I'm going to doc MrP.

You had a major problem with this, which makes me extremely suspicious of you, because this plan should narrow down exactly who the scum is. Additionally, a mislynch isn't game-over, but it means me and the mafia have to battle out at night. So a mislynch today is a 50-50 chance of losing/winning, so long as I'm not that mislynch.

So basically, my assumption is that mafia wants to either lynch me today, or mislynch. Those are the only two chances of winning. The former being 100%, the latter being 50%.

The fact that you argued for me initially, and now are settling for maybe zero, gives me inclination to think it's you. But again, the day has come to a complete halt because we don't actually know what's going on with zero, so town is already hamstringed.

And this is why it's so difficult for town to win with you and zero alive at the game end. There can clearly only be one mafia left, but the both of you are completely insane. It makes the decision 1000% more difficult.



spurgeonryan said:
I am stupid. Believing in all these power roles, and what more a Godfather. Like prof said, maybe as a hint so we do not think too much about it, even town lies. I do not even think there are any power roles. Cop is really strong for a game like this. But with two mafia, even if a doc is here, that is not as far fetched. Godfather is crazy powerful.

unvote: prof

Did you lie to make zero believe you were going to protect him so that you trust him or do you really have a doc power? Why speak in riddles so that no one knows what is going on?

What riddles are you talking about. I speak plain english.

I have a doc power. I protected the claimed cop twice now.



Around the Network

@spurge - I will punish this situation arcordingly, I have asked for a replacement some time ago, but nobody answered - sadly enough.



Personally, I think Prof should remove his vote from Spurge. Sure we might win this game on the off chance that he's mafia but if he gets Miss lynched and Prof doesn't make the right decision we might not see tomorrow. I think that Spurge did the right thing by removing his vote from Prof, if he is doc (and I personally believe he is) lynching him would definitely be the end of town.

If no one dies tonight and Zero doesn't come online, we can then come to the conclusion that Prof either did the right decision or Zero is Mafia. Is someone dies tonight and zero still hasn't come online, then the killer must be one of us.



Send a Friend Request On PSN :P

spurgeonryan said:
Stefl1504 said:
A time-limit has been set to friday evening CET, zero has been mod poked

So zero has until 5pm CEntral European time? Is that what that means? Because 5pm is usually beginning of eventing and end of afternoon. So we have about three hours.

 

Maybe Mr. P you should put a vote on zero, in case prof does not come back in, that way at least it will still be tied when the day ends. It is morning now, I am off for four days but prof may be on his way to work or something.

2 hours 45 minutes left in all. 

Vote: Zero



Send a Friend Request On PSN :P

Please note that a time-limit extension of 24 hours can be forced by a 33% rule, as well as a time-limit imposed by the same amount of players agreeing, such a time-limit is non-extendable and the exact time will be determined by the mods.

Means it needs 2 players to extend it. Votals soon™



unvote
Vote: no lynch