By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Sony - Uncharted 4: A Thief's End Review Thread - MC: 93 / GR: 92.70%

Tagged games:

CenterYharnham on 15 May 2016
mornelithe said:
CenterYharnham said:

Not at all.  If people involved in making the game want to dispute a bogus review then I think they should.  

I don't think, however, that it should involve any of us or a petition started on Change.org.  

You know why Naughty Dog isn't getting involved with this one guy's negative opinion?  Because they have confidence in the fantastic game they've created and don't care about one bogus review that no one took seriously in the first place.  I think it's time we grow up and do the same.  

Yeah, but you weren't involved in making the game, so your opinion is irrelevant.  I defer to Troy Baker here :)

Bolded: Obviously, an invalid statement.  Metacritic took it seriously enough to utilize the score in their meta. 

Post Moderated - Myself



Around the Network
mornelithe on 15 May 2016
Slade6alpha said:
mornelithe said:

Yeah, and shared it on Twitter.

I mean cool for him, but do petitions ever work? 

Couldn't tell you, I don't honestly care, nor did I sign it.  I just follow Troy on Twitter and saw a tweet about it earlier, and given the insistance that only people who worked on Uncharted have any right to fight it, I felt it relevant to point out.



Spade on 15 May 2016
BraLoD said:
Btw, it's over 1000. Suck it Boutros!

Mocking another VGC user. 

Hovers over report button :) 

INB4 Broload throws backseat moderating at me.  



https://www.trueachievements.com/gamercards/SliferCynDelta.png%5B/IMG%5D">https://www.trueachievements.com/gamer/SliferCynDelta"><img src="https://www.trueachievements.com/gamercards/SliferCynDelta.png

mornelithe on 15 May 2016
CenterYharnham said:
mornelithe said:

Yeah, but you weren't involved in making the game, so your opinion is irrelevant.  I defer to Troy Baker here :)

Bolded: Obviously, an invalid statement.  Metacritic took it seriously enough to utilize the score in their meta. 

Neither were you so why not buy a self-help book and get back to living your life.  

If you've still got some free time you could also check out our Constitution and read the part under the Bill of Rights titled: Amendment I :)

Poor bait.  Clearly I'm still living my life, unless you think I'm some kind of AI bot, just responding to threads online.  An interesting thought, but not accurate.  

Not sure why I should re-read the Constitution, not only am I not involved in this in any way (haven't bought the game, haven't signed the petition), I'm not laying claim to who has a right to express an opinion or sign something.   You were already all over that before I got here.

Also, that petition doesn't request the Government do anything, and this may come as a surprise to you but the 1st Amendment only protects you from censorship by the Government (1st Amendment does tons more (Freedom of the Press, Freedom of Religion, Freedom of Association), but for the purposes of this issue, it's the only part that matters).   So, unless that petition is asking the Government to do something, you citing the 1st Amendment isn't relevant to the situation at hand.



Spade on 15 May 2016
BraLoD said:
Slade6alpha said:

Mocking another VGC user. 

Hovers over report button :) 

INB4 Broload throws backseat moderating at me.  

Boutros and his punny nearly 34K post thread deserved it!

Also, don't worry, Trucks is coming for ya.

Damn bra, shots fired. Dude's not even a mod anymore  

I see what you did there

Basically saying Rol's coming after me. 

OT: Is there any chance for this meta going up or down, or is this is? 

 



https://www.trueachievements.com/gamercards/SliferCynDelta.png%5B/IMG%5D">https://www.trueachievements.com/gamer/SliferCynDelta"><img src="https://www.trueachievements.com/gamercards/SliferCynDelta.png

Around the Network
Bryank75 on 15 May 2016
BraLoD said:
Slade6alpha said:

Damn bra, shots fired. Dude's not even a mod anymore  

I see what you did there

Basically saying Rol's coming after me. 

OT: Is there any chance for this meta going up or down, or is this is? 

It can still go both ways, it's high 93s, but we just saw a click bait score can make it drop at once, and it can still climb back to 94 as well.

Tom Chick over at Quarter to Three has to post his review but he only started today (I think), I was talking to him on twitter... his scale is out of 5 stars and he can be scathing. might be looking at 40 / 60 there because of the "find a box and move it to climb" bits.... 

He rated TLOU 60, I think. 



ModBod on 15 May 2016

But dude there is another review by WP that actually has a score and it's a 4/4 which is a percfect score.. so what the fucking fuck i was so pissed when i saw that they added that bullshit review and thanks to that im done with metacritic forever .

Me to



Bryank75 on 15 May 2016
BraLoD said:
Bryank75 said:

Tom Chick over at Quarter to Three has to post his review but he only started today (I think), I was talking to him on twitter... his scale is out of 5 stars and he can be scathing. might be looking at 40 / 60 there because of the "find a box and move it to climb" bits.... 

He rated TLOU 60, I think. 

So QtT will post a review... sigh, 92, here comes Uncharted 4.

Yes, he most certainly will. He was surprisingly polite and reposted all of his old Uncharted reviews on his new site for me to read.

 

Edge also have to review it and they will be about 2 weeks, I think. 



Kowan on 15 May 2016
Bryank75 said:
BraLoD said:

It can still go both ways, it's high 93s, but we just saw a click bait score can make it drop at once, and it can still climb back to 94 as well.

Tom Chick over at Quarter to Three has to post his review but he only started today (I think), I was talking to him on twitter... his scale is out of 5 stars and he can be scathing. might be looking at 40 / 60 there because of the "find a box and move it to climb" bits.... 

He rated TLOU 60, I think. 

But there are so few of those in Uncharted 4. And most of them are for finding optional and missable treasures. The actual puzzles are really creative and great to behold, even. If he uses  that as a reason to pull down his rating, then that's  a questionable decision.



Bryank75 on 15 May 2016
Kowan said:
Bryank75 said:

Tom Chick over at Quarter to Three has to post his review but he only started today (I think), I was talking to him on twitter... his scale is out of 5 stars and he can be scathing. might be looking at 40 / 60 there because of the "find a box and move it to climb" bits.... 

He rated TLOU 60, I think. 

But there are so few of those in Uncharted 4. And most of them are for finding optional and missable treasures. The actual puzzles are really creative and great to behold, even. If he uses  that as a reason to pull down his rating, then that's  a questionable decision.

I am just guessing.... he is a known contrarian and scores a lot of big games low. Lets wait and see...