Prob Sonic Boom, its certainly not as bad as Sonic 06, trust me on that. The game is actually ok- not good, not terrible, for every good moment (there are a few), there is always a poor element to balance it out. If it had been in the oven longer it might have been elevated to above average.

Edit- forgot to mention Heavy Rain too, lovely graphics, but strip that away and you have a game of Simon says. Honestly, shaking your Playstation controller from side to side to brush your characters teeth lol, its no different from the waggle games that the Wii was mocked for.

Oh yes, the original Metroid would like to have a talk with you.

I'm sure there are more examples out there, I just can't think of them.

Earthbound. However, it's been more than 5 years since I last played that game.

Gonna add Uncharted and FIFA 07 (the only one I've played)