*edit coax a counter-claim

*edit hopes that town would fall for it.

It's the same recklessness from before from Spurge, which is why i focused on padib when it was down to the four of us. If Spurge is scum he's doing an awful job of it, similar to Smeags, really.

I would look at stefl, Yoshiya, and wonk. I suspect that two of the three of them are the other scum, along with two out of the three of spurge, Astro, and Smeags.

The second string of possibles were the people who voted for padib but weren't around for the last 12 hours or so before the day ended. Again, my thought is that the voting was close enough that there is little cause for any "bus-throwing", because scum could've pulled off a win there if they were able to marshal their ranks. They were unable to do so, though. Some people may have put their vote on padib and simply not been present when the tide really turned against him, but in lieu of deeper-level thinking, the big 6 scum suspects are the non-voters and the people who voted for me (or Yoshiya who is a little of both, since he claimed he had voted for me)

You say that as if his behavior last game wasn't reckless, especially when he was pressured. I could always be making a mistake tho and tunelling him. Of those you listed who are you most likely going to vote for today given the new information that spurg may be a tracker and smeags may have visted you last night? Also Why do you think spurg asked me where I was last night, if not to say he tracked me?

I didn't pay too much attention to last game until about the last day or so, i'll admit, so i wasn't much up on what spurge was up to.

It does seem odd that spurge only now comes out with evidence to incriminate one of the other very suspicious users, and it would cement the idea that, whatever else, spurge and smeags aren't on the same team. If that means smeags is mafia and spurge is town or smeags is sk and spurge is mafia, i'm not sure.

It could make the safest bet be a vote against Smeags. The worst-case-scenario there, a Smeags town flip, wouldn't be so horrid because if he's one of us he's doing a hideous job of it and we would be better off without him.

Okay, worst-worst is if Smeags is jester and we end the game immediately by lynching him. I wouldn't put that past theprof either.

This is why i advise patience. Perhaps a piece to the puzzle will reveal itself that helps lend credit or discredit to spurge's story here.

Is he trying to incriminate smeags? Looks to me he is trying to say smeags is town and set him up for a doctor or protector claim. After all he has been discrediting those that have suspected smeags and saying they are wrong.

if I make any mistakes my apologies, had only been causally reading the thread from the start and since it got reduced to 4 day one it was even less so.

So spurge was one of the four and at the start of that had the most vote with 3. He at the point had already claimed ness but no role.

He's now claiming he tracked Smeags to khan last night after I'm not sure how many votes on him.

At this point I don't think he should be getting any more votes until we've at least had smeags come in to say if he did go to khan and say why. If smeags says he didn't we can lynch spurge and get the flip to see if he was what he said, if so smeags would be the next target.
Obviously I don't want this order of events rushed, just we should do what we can to verify claims.

we do also still need to look further into radish with his friendly neighbor claim, should be able to test it out within a night or two.

khan will be a little harder to confirm, but he's low priority of roles to test out at the moment

I do agree with your point tho. Smeags may be a better option. For now, lets see why smeags was visiting you.

Unvote:

Vote; Smeags

On a side note so far the roles are within the realm of the characters. Like me for example I am jigglypuff so I can put someone to sleep and make their vote not count and everyone loves jigglypuff so I have double vote. Looking over Ness I don't really see how he could be tracker? http://supersmashbros.wikia.com/wiki/Ness "Ness is also a master of the psychic powers called PSI, and knows PSI attacks like PK Flash, PK Rockin', PSI Shield, Lifeup, Healing, Hypnosis, Paralysis and Teleport." If I were theprof I would make him a roleblocker if anything at al considering her has hynosis and paralysis.

another set of posts that stand out to me.