As before, I say we need to trust the scan results we have which means Spurge is scum. If he is not, we need to take a good look at Khan. Right now one of them is lying.

The question that i am lying would come down to the fact that if i am, i've nuked half or so of my own scum team for some nefarious purpose. If i'm playing a game of deception on that level, than mafia's already lost because this plan is too stupid to possibly work, or town has already lost because i'm playing on a level so high that no-one can comprehend it.

Or i'm telling the truth. Occam's razor's gotten us this far...

I really don't think Spurge has ever accused an actual scum...

Just to be clear Khan, I am not saying I think you are the liar ...

At this point I'm just going to do it.

Vote: Spurgeonryan

This is very weird. It actually seems like spurge is telling the truth. I mean I can't confirm it's Imp, but someone other than Khan was there. Lucky guess on spurge's part? Or perhaps he's a scum tracker? I was a scum watcher once. I realize this sounds terrible, but based on what I saw I really think maybe it's best we listen to Imp's request to not claim just yet. At the same time, I completely believe Khan and his power at this point, so I think spurge's item is real and means he's anti-town. I want a spurge reveal so bad right now. He'll probably be my vote today. Sorry spurge, but while Yoshiya's lynch was a group effort to some degree, the point is that Khan's power was right, and we wouldn't have caught Yoshiya without him. And you're a proven liar, there's that, so if one of you is lying, I'm inclined to think it's you.

This is how it's been the whole game with spurge. He convinces me he's town at the first of the day, then later on all the evidence stacks up against him. Today it was that I haven't seen him throw any actual scum under the entire game. 

I can honestly trust everyone but you. Some not as much, but you have the most evidence pointing toward you. 

I didn't want to prove me, I wanted to prove you. I dared you because I knew I could confirm it by watching myself. If you feel like wasting another scan on me, that's town's loss.

Also, scum always has night talk, it's part of the basic rules of the game. It's day talk that is in question. I'm just saying. Oh, and redirectors, according to the wiki,

"A Redirector is a role that causes all actions taken on a particular Night by a specific player to target a specific second player instead of whatever their original target was."

So yoshiya could have chosen you to make your night actions target another player instead of him. So for example he could have redirected you to radish so you'd think your scan of him was town, when you were actually scanning radish. But he'd have to know you were targeting him.

you could be scum tracker, you could have a passive role that let's you know who targeted you, your scum mate could have told you I targeted you, i'm sure there are other options as well. Even if you straight up tracked me that doesn't mean anything, you could still be a mafia tracker. with a bat.