Sparks its funny you keep referring to last game as proof that nickels is scum.

this post, and several others remind me of hylian padib and nickles from last game.

assuming reasoning, suspecting teamwork, using faulty logic.

@everyone

im down for lynching carl, sparks, or astro

I was talking about the other factions he mentioned outright. As for how I knew, that's what it said in my PM. I won't go any further than that.

Back to impertinence. At the time, it looked like he assumed Carl had to belong to the factions he mentioned, when nobody had any idea about anything yet. It was that apparent assumption that set off my alarm. I didn't pay any attention to Carl's quotes. I had dismissed them as fluff, and didn't bother to Google them myself. I didn't even realize he was quoting different factions, since I only played the 2D one over a decade ago. I thought, where did he even get those? And honestly, at the time I thought he was noob enough to have made that mistake. Then, as time passed, it seemed less and less likely. He wasn't as noobish as I'd thought initially.

He later cleared it up by saying he Googled it, promted by Carl's quotes themselves. I guess I could see that being true. I guess I don't really suspect him anymore either.

Do you disagree? You think his argument against Carl is well based? If so, show me which parts you think are well founded arguments, cuz it all smells like shit to me.

The reason I suspect him is that I don't think he himself buys what he's saying about Carl, and I don't think you do either.

Regarding this bit. I'm not going to write "btw, this is just a Day1 vote" beside every post I make.

It's funny since you're the one who convinced me about Day1 actions to begin with. So yeah, I have no better suspect to vote for, and I'm not going vote no-lynch either. If anyone is to be lynched, I'd vote him.

Sidenote: does anyone besides radish think we shouldn't have a lynch toDay? If so, you better speak up since the Day is ending soon.

Tagging, as I believe I'm Fusioncode's replacement. Awaiting final confirmation from WoW. Almost caught up with the posts.

Unfortunately I'm not sure I'll have time to wait for WoW's confirmation before going to bed. I'll try to get up early to give my impressions before the end of the day. I can't exactly give my impressions now because I still don't have a role card, so forgive me.

HylianSwordsman replaces Fusioncode effective immediately.

Let's all welcome him.

Welcome Hylian, are you on the same team as last time?

On Astro:

Do not like.

Notorious lurking from a player who has played the game before. First post after checking came days into the game and was basically a heads up that more lurking was coming. Says something about posting one large post a day with observations, well, that isn't happening.

Next post is a lame excuse for inactivity, he has all these great posts but second guesses himself and never posts http://gamrconnect.vgchartz.com/post.php?id=6667427

Earlier today he promised a bigger post again within a couple of hours, but that isn't coming either, what we do get though is a vote on Nickles lynch train when he senses the chance to get him hammered and end the day. "To make the process smoother" he says.

Extra strong HoS on Astro.

on padib:

I don't have enough experience to do a lot of meta playing with any hope of success, but considering this game was set up and balanced before anyone thought padib would be able to play I doubt he is scum. I am assuming it would be much easier for the mod(s) to just add another town player without upsetting the balance of the game.

If this is a misunderstanding of how mafia games get set up, please let me know. Until then I will consider padib as confirmed town for me.

It's been a little longer. Now would be a good time to let us know who you suspect could be mafia. Night is near.