By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Gaming Discussion - Starcraft Mafia - Game Thread - Concluded

it will eventually just come down to who we believe the most.
Padib still says it's wright, and wright obviously says its not him.
2 people not cleared have a least been slightly tested/ by people with similar roles. If the nuker was given a fake claim that was one of those that opens up another.
Imp doesn't have a scan on him or a role that he can confirm with someone since we can't share our stats and once again if we believe in a given fake claim it's moot.

for me it's really going to come down to it being between wright and imp, and if padib can try killing him again tonight that's our opportunity to try them both.

Otherwise we can try and hunt something from the other three kahn, the replacement doing out mod a favor, radish who has been too quiet most the game, and white who was in contention for a lynch at one point.

I'll stick with the simple plan with a back up.

Vote impertinence



Around the Network

I'm going to explain something for you guys that should put everything into perspective.

1
My full role claim is
Jim Raynor
This is my town- mod confirmation and I pick the lynch
Bitch Slap- Slap a player, you deactivate any personal cloaking devices and are informed of having done so
Bro Fist- pick a player, you take half of their damage if they are attacked at night.

What this tells me is that my role is half cop, half doc, and weakened forms of which.
I cannot find dark templar, and I cannot heal damage done to a player
This confirms to me that there are full versions of my bastard roles. 1 full cop and 1 full doc
This was how I knew that carl was our doc, who heals damage
Wright is 100% our town cop who can find any invisible unit (mine is just for the ghost)

2.
Padib is 100% not the ghost because he attacked wright last night, while I was the ghost's target. Unless targeting two players with different attacks is also a skill padib has, Padib is not the ghost. Furthermore, Wright SAW his attacker last night. The attacker wasn't invisible. Additionally, on the night when padib could potentially have turned off his cloaking, he was invulnerable to attacks. This wouldn't be fair meta-wise.

3.
Wright was visible to padib last night as well, meaning he was not cloaked.

4.
All the scans are therefore correct.
Cleared players (not the nuke) are
Padib, trucks, eric, cone, carl, wonk, prof, wright

5.
This leaves, and ONLY leaves these players as potential nuke
Imp
Khan
Radish
WEPL

Does everyone agree? If you have questions, feel free to ask. But I think this is as conclusive as it can possibly get.



I just figured something out.
It's imp, or radish.

Those are the two.
I guarantee it. 100%



I can't say why, it's modkillable.



theprof00 said:
radishhead said:
I was just appearing to say that I'm sorry my internet has literally been garbage today and the whole thing crashes as soon as I try to load a page - and that I'm hoping to be able to read it all tomorrow (~200 posts?), but I just saw there was a whole thing regarding me, so I'll try to stick around a little longer.

For the record (I haven't read all the posts yet, so I don't know if this is actually the case) - but if Spurge is claiming to have received information that claims that I'm anti-town, then that's 100% not true, and if that's what he's saying then I must vote him (I won't yet though, since I'm not sure if that's actually what's happening here)

He hasn't.

He said he scanned you for your race and the results were hazy.

Yet spurge didn't push for radish.

O man. THis is a breakthrough, guys. I need to read just a little bit more.



Around the Network
impertinence said:
It's a shame we have to worry about the nuke first and let prof live, but that's the game I guess.

Despite all this bickering and people not being able to see past the meta, we have not moved of the basic premise. Padib and Wright can't both be telling the truth. Easiest way to check is to lynch wright. If padib has this crazy role we're done with the nuke and can get rid of the scum and WoW has indeed put together a crazy game. Flipping wright also tests profs claims. If wright does flip town and cop to boot, the nuke is almost certainly Spurge.

If we flip padib and he checks out according to his claim we'll still have scum trying to pretend wright just happened to be there when the ghost attacked padib and we're running in circles. Perhaps town would have the sense to lynch wright next, but I can already imagine the fun with that scenario. If padibs flip shows he's been lying we're in trouble as it doesn't lead directly to anyone being the nuke (though many would suspect spurge probably)
If we flip Spurge we might or might not get lucky.If he is indeed the nuke, good news appart from prof becoming even more intolerable. If he is not the nuke we're stuck in a similar rut. Who is the nuke then, we'd have to go by the word of a claimed slapper who is lying through his teeth and the claimed nuke who prof has gone to extreme steps to defend.

The best lynch is wright, and now prof can tear into the illogical reasoning for many pages if he'd like. I invite other players to consider this reasoning and give your critisism of the reasoning

This is bullshit. ANd you're bullshit.

This entire post was meant to send us into a runaround day 3 and 4.

It's my opinion that you vote this player, town.



Trucks, remember that game where you were the serial killer and I copped you and I refused to say why I knew you were scum but I kept pushing all these different angles on you?

It feels exactly how impertinence is playing right now.




unvote
vote: impertinence



theprof00 said:

unvote
vote: impertinence


lol you just unvoted and revoted him



Wonktonodi said:
theprof00 said:

unvote
vote: impertinence


lol you just unvoted and revoted him

haha woops I saw a vote count above that had me on padib, and couldn't find my vote afterwards. :D