By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Gaming - Gamespot, consistent gaming journalism

I'm personally not reading reviews for The Last of Us (I've imposed a media lock down on myself), but I know Gamespot occasionally goes against the grain. Bear in mind that they gave their 2009 Game of the Year award to Demon's Souls over Uncharted 2 (which I actually agreed with).  With that said, an 8 isn't bad at all, and regardless, the only thing that matters is how you the player feels about the game.



Around the Network
gigantor21 said:


SMH @ people complaining that a game they haven't even played yet got an excellent score instead of a perfect one. THIS is the reason that scores are so overinflated and unreliable.


I'm against perfect scores. No game deserves 10/10, but...

 

did you read the review?



There is already a review thread. We don't want a thread for every reviewer who didn't give the goddamn game a perfect score.

Hey, Wright. How are you?



Deyon said:
There is already a review thread. We don't want a thread for every reviewer who didn't give the goddamn game a perfect score.

Hey, Wright. How are you?


It's not about the score, it's about the review.

 

My head hurts.



Wright said:
...


Done, already.


thanks!



Around the Network
kitler53 said:
Wright said:
...


Done, already.


thanks!


Nope. Thank you for the warming. Guess I went for the easy route when writing the thread.



Wright said:
gigantor21 said:


SMH @ people complaining that a game they haven't even played yet got an excellent score instead of a perfect one. THIS is the reason that scores are so overinflated and unreliable.


I'm against perfect scores. No game deserves 10/10, but...

 

did you read the review?

Of course not, and I'm not going to.

The way you made it sound, I thought they gave it a 5 or something. But an 8 instead of a 9 or 10? This is pure overreaction.



Have some time to kill? Read my shitty games blog. http://www.pixlbit.com/blogs/586/gigantor21

:D

Wright said:
kitler53 said:

thanks!


Nope. Thank you for the warming. Guess I went for the easy route when writing the thread.

He warmed you? awwww that's so sweet :*



gigantor21 said:

Of course not, and I'm not going to.

The way you made it sound, I thought they gave it a 5 or something. But an 8 instead of a 9 or 10? This is pure overreaction.


My problem is not the score, my friend. I don't agree with 10s either. But that's not the point, the review itself is the point.



So what is wrong with the review? I read it, the parts I could be bothered to anyway, saw some interesting mechanics explained, and some points brought up that would keep me from buying the game. All in all, boring read if you're not particularly interested in the game, but why does this review warrant it's own thread?