16 Santana- Black Magic Woman

15 Cream- Sunshine of Your Love
15 Iron Maiden- Number of the Beast (+)

14 Rolling Stones- Paint It Black
14 ZZ Top- La Grange
14 Black Sabbath- Paranoid

13 Aerosmith- Same Old Song and Dance
13 The Devil Went Down to Georgia
13 Weezer- My Name Is Jonas

12 Foghat- Slow Ride
12 Pearl Jam- Evenflow
12 Tenacious D- The Metal

11 The Who- The Seeker
11 Mountain- Mississippi Queen

10 Poison- Talk Dirty to Me
10 Pat Benatar- Hit Me With Your Best Shot
10 Scorpions- Rock You Like a Hurricane
10 Alice Cooper- School’s Out
10 Living Colour- Cult of Personality

9 Slash- Guitar Battle
9 Blue Oyster Cult- Cities on Flame with Rock and Roll

5 Priestess- Lay Down

4 Smashing Pumpkins- Cherub Rock

0 Sonic Youth- Kool Thing (---)

Rules:
(1) Add one point for your favorite song.
(2) Minus 3 Points for your least favorite song.
(3) 1 vote per person per hour.
(4) Copy and Paste these rules along with each vote.

ELIMINATED

Slayer- Raining blood, Kiss- Rock and Roll All Nite, DragonForce- Through The Fire and Flames, Beastie Boys - Sabotage, Queens of the Stone Age- 3’s and 7’s, Heart- Barracuda, Eric Johnson- Cliffs of Dover, In Flames - Take This Life, Rage Against the Machine- Bulls on Parade, AFI- Miss Murder, Muse- Knights of Cydonia, The Killers- When You Were Young, Matchbook Romance- Monsters, Guns N Roses- Welcome to the Jungle, The Strokes- Reptilia, Disturbed- Stricken The Dead Kennedy’s- Holiday in Cambodia, Red Hot Chili Peppers- Suck My Kiss, Stevie Ray Vaughn- Pride and Joy, Social Distortion- Story of My Life, Bloc Party- Hellicopter, Sonic Youth- Kool Thing

16 Santana- Black Magic Woman
16 Iron Maiden- Number of the Beast (+)

15 Cream- Sunshine of Your Love

14 Rolling Stones- Paint It Black
14 ZZ Top- La Grange
14 Black Sabbath- Paranoid

13 Aerosmith- Same Old Song and Dance
13 The Devil Went Down to Georgia
13 Weezer- My Name Is Jonas

12 Foghat- Slow Ride
12 Pearl Jam- Evenflow
12 Tenacious D- The Metal

11 The Who- The Seeker
11 Mountain- Mississippi Queen

10 Poison- Talk Dirty to Me
10 Pat Benatar- Hit Me With Your Best Shot
10 Scorpions- Rock You Like a Hurricane
10 Alice Cooper- School’s Out
10 Living Colour- Cult of Personality

9 Slash- Guitar Battle
9 Blue Oyster Cult- Cities on Flame with Rock and Roll

5 Priestess- Lay Down

1 Smashing Pumpkins- Cherub Rock (---)

Rules:
(1) Add one point for your favorite song.
(2) Minus 3 Points for your least favorite song.
(3) 1 vote per person per hour.
(4) Copy and Paste these rules along with each vote.

ELIMINATED

Slayer- Raining blood, Kiss- Rock and Roll All Nite, DragonForce- Through The Fire and Flames, Beastie Boys - Sabotage, Queens of the Stone Age- 3’s and 7’s, Heart- Barracuda, Eric Johnson- Cliffs of Dover, In Flames - Take This Life, Rage Against the Machine- Bulls on Parade, AFI- Miss Murder, Muse- Knights of Cydonia, The Killers- When You Were Young, Matchbook Romance- Monsters, Guns N Roses- Welcome to the Jungle, The Strokes- Reptilia, Disturbed- Stricken The Dead Kennedy’s- Holiday in Cambodia, Red Hot Chili Peppers- Suck My Kiss, Stevie Ray Vaughn- Pride and Joy, Social Distortion- Story of My Life, Bloc Party- Hellicopter, Sonic Youth- Kool Thing

16 Santana- Black Magic Woman

15 Cream- Sunshine of Your Love

14 Rolling Stones- Paint It Black
14 ZZ Top- La Grange
14 Black Sabbath- Paranoid

13 Aerosmith- Same Old Song and Dance
13 The Devil Went Down to Georgia
13 Weezer- My Name Is Jonas
13 Iron Maiden- Number of the Beast (---)

12 Foghat- Slow Ride
12 Pearl Jam- Evenflow
12 Tenacious D- The Metal

11 Alice Cooper- School’s Out (+)
11 The Who- The Seeker
11 Mountain- Mississippi Queen

10 Poison- Talk Dirty to Me
10 Pat Benatar- Hit Me With Your Best Shot
10 Scorpions- Rock You Like a Hurricane
10 Living Colour- Cult of Personality

9 Slash- Guitar Battle
9 Blue Oyster Cult- Cities on Flame with Rock and Roll

5 Priestess- Lay Down

1 Smashing Pumpkins- Cherub Rock

Rules:
(1) Add one point for your favorite song.
(2) Minus 3 Points for your least favorite song.
(3) 1 vote per person per hour.
(4) Copy and Paste these rules along with each vote.

ELIMINATED

Slayer- Raining blood, Kiss- Rock and Roll All Nite, DragonForce- Through The Fire and Flames, Beastie Boys - Sabotage, Queens of the Stone Age- 3’s and 7’s, Heart- Barracuda, Eric Johnson- Cliffs of Dover, In Flames - Take This Life, Rage Against the Machine- Bulls on Parade, AFI- Miss Murder, Muse- Knights of Cydonia, The Killers- When You Were Young, Matchbook Romance- Monsters, Guns N Roses- Welcome to the Jungle, The Strokes- Reptilia, Disturbed- Stricken The Dead Kennedy’s- Holiday in Cambodia, Red Hot Chili Peppers- Suck My Kiss, Stevie Ray Vaughn- Pride and Joy, Social Distortion- Story of My Life, Bloc Party- Hellicopter, Sonic Youth- Kool Thing

16 Santana- Black Magic Woman

15 Cream- Sunshine of Your Love

14 Rolling Stones- Paint It Black
14 ZZ Top- La Grange
14 Black Sabbath- Paranoid
14 Iron Maiden- Number of the Beast (+)

13 Aerosmith- Same Old Song and Dance
13 The Devil Went Down to Georgia
13 Weezer- My Name Is Jonas

12 Foghat- Slow Ride
12 Pearl Jam- Evenflow
12 Tenacious D- The Metal

11 Alice Cooper- School’s Out
11 The Who- The Seeker
11 Mountain- Mississippi Queen

10 Poison- Talk Dirty to Me
10 Pat Benatar- Hit Me With Your Best Shot
10 Scorpions- Rock You Like a Hurricane
10 Living Colour- Cult of Personality

9 Blue Oyster Cult- Cities on Flame with Rock and Roll

6 Slash- Guitar Battle (---)

5 Priestess- Lay Down

1 Smashing Pumpkins- Cherub Rock

Rules:
(1) Add one point for your favorite song.
(2) Minus 3 Points for your least favorite song.
(3) 1 vote per person per hour.
(4) Copy and Paste these rules along with each vote.

ELIMINATED

Slayer- Raining blood, Kiss- Rock and Roll All Nite, DragonForce- Through The Fire and Flames, Beastie Boys - Sabotage, Queens of the Stone Age- 3’s and 7’s, Heart- Barracuda, Eric Johnson- Cliffs of Dover, In Flames - Take This Life, Rage Against the Machine- Bulls on Parade, AFI- Miss Murder, Muse- Knights of Cydonia, The Killers- When You Were Young, Matchbook Romance- Monsters, Guns N Roses- Welcome to the Jungle, The Strokes- Reptilia, Disturbed- Stricken The Dead Kennedy’s- Holiday in Cambodia, Red Hot Chili Peppers- Suck My Kiss, Stevie Ray Vaughn- Pride and Joy, Social Distortion- Story of My Life, Bloc Party- Hellicopter, Sonic Youth- Kool Thing

16 Santana- Black Magic Woman

15 Cream- Sunshine of Your Love

14 Rolling Stones- Paint It Black
14 ZZ Top- La Grange
14 Black Sabbath- Paranoid

13 Aerosmith- Same Old Song and Dance
13 The Devil Went Down to Georgia
13 Weezer- My Name Is Jonas

12 Foghat- Slow Ride
12 Pearl Jam- Evenflow
12 Tenacious D- The Metal
12 Alice Cooper- School’s Out (+)

11 Iron Maiden- Number of the Beast (---)
11 The Who- The Seeker
11 Mountain- Mississippi Queen

10 Poison- Talk Dirty to Me
10 Pat Benatar- Hit Me With Your Best Shot
10 Scorpions- Rock You Like a Hurricane
10 Living Colour- Cult of Personality

9 Blue Oyster Cult- Cities on Flame with Rock and Roll

6 Slash- Guitar Battle

5 Priestess- Lay Down

1 Smashing Pumpkins- Cherub Rock

Rules:
(1) Add one point for your favorite song.
(2) Minus 3 Points for your least favorite song.
(3) 1 vote per person per hour.
(4) Copy and Paste these rules along with each vote.

ELIMINATED

Slayer- Raining blood, Kiss- Rock and Roll All Nite, DragonForce- Through The Fire and Flames, Beastie Boys - Sabotage, Queens of the Stone Age- 3’s and 7’s, Heart- Barracuda, Eric Johnson- Cliffs of Dover, In Flames - Take This Life, Rage Against the Machine- Bulls on Parade, AFI- Miss Murder, Muse- Knights of Cydonia, The Killers- When You Were Young, Matchbook Romance- Monsters, Guns N Roses- Welcome to the Jungle, The Strokes- Reptilia, Disturbed- Stricken The Dead Kennedy’s- Holiday in Cambodia, Red Hot Chili Peppers- Suck My Kiss, Stevie Ray Vaughn- Pride and Joy, Social Distortion- Story of My Life, Bloc Party- Hellicopter, Sonic Youth- Kool Thing

This "subtract three" idea was rather foolish, because it allows one guy to outvote up to three others, provided the other three don't vote consistently.  In the end, the final song will be what's hated the least, rather than what's liked the most.

16 Santana- Black Magic Woman

15 Cream- Sunshine of Your Love

14 Rolling Stones- Paint It Black
14 ZZ Top- La Grange
14 Black Sabbath- Paranoid

13 Aerosmith- Same Old Song and Dance
13 The Devil Went Down to Georgia
13 Weezer- My Name Is Jonas

12 Foghat- Slow Ride
12 Iron Maiden- Number of the Beast (+)
12 Pearl Jam- Evenflow
12 Tenacious D- The Metal
12 Alice Cooper- School’s Out

11 The Who- The Seeker
11 Mountain- Mississippi Queen

10 Poison- Talk Dirty to Me
10 Pat Benatar- Hit Me With Your Best Shot
10 Scorpions- Rock You Like a Hurricane
10 Living Colour- Cult of Personality

9 Blue Oyster Cult- Cities on Flame with Rock and Roll

6 Slash- Guitar Battle

3 Priestess- Lay Down (--)

0 Smashing Pumpkins- Cherub Rock (-) Eliminated!

Rules:
(1) Add one point for your favorite song.
(2) Minus 3 Points for your least favorite song.
(3) 1 vote per person per hour.
(4) Copy and Paste these rules along with each vote.

ELIMINATED

Slayer- Raining blood, Kiss- Rock and Roll All Nite, DragonForce- Through The Fire and Flames, Beastie Boys - Sabotage, Queens of the Stone Age- 3’s and 7’s, Heart- Barracuda, Eric Johnson- Cliffs of Dover, In Flames - Take This Life, Rage Against the Machine- Bulls on Parade, AFI- Miss Murder, Muse- Knights of Cydonia, The Killers- When You Were Young, Matchbook Romance- Monsters, Guns N Roses- Welcome to the Jungle, The Strokes- Reptilia, Disturbed- Stricken The Dead Kennedy’s- Holiday in Cambodia, Red Hot Chili Peppers- Suck My Kiss, Stevie Ray Vaughn- Pride and Joy, Social Distortion- Story of My Life, Bloc Party- Hellicopter, Sonic Youth- Kool Thing, Smashing Pumpkins- Cherub Rock

16 Santana- Black Magic Woman

15 Cream- Sunshine of Your Love

14 Rolling Stones- Paint It Black
14 ZZ Top- La Grange
14 Black Sabbath- Paranoid

13 Aerosmith- Same Old Song and Dance
13 The Devil Went Down to Georgia
13 Weezer- My Name Is Jonas
13 Alice Cooper- School’s Out (+)

12 Foghat- Slow Ride
12 Pearl Jam- Evenflow
12 Tenacious D- The Metal

11 The Who- The Seeker
11 Mountain- Mississippi Queen

10 Poison- Talk Dirty to Me
10 Pat Benatar- Hit Me With Your Best Shot
10 Scorpions- Rock You Like a Hurricane
10 Living Colour- Cult of Personality

9 Blue Oyster Cult- Cities on Flame with Rock and Roll
9 Iron Maiden- Number of the Beast (---)

6 Slash- Guitar Battle

3 Priestess- Lay Down


Rules:
(1) Add one point for your favorite song.
(2) Minus 3 Points for your least favorite song.
(3) 1 vote per person per hour.
(4) Copy and Paste these rules along with each vote.

ELIMINATED

Slayer- Raining blood, Kiss- Rock and Roll All Nite, DragonForce- Through The Fire and Flames, Beastie Boys - Sabotage, Queens of the Stone Age- 3’s and 7’s, Heart- Barracuda, Eric Johnson- Cliffs of Dover, In Flames - Take This Life, Rage Against the Machine- Bulls on Parade, AFI- Miss Murder, Muse- Knights of Cydonia, The Killers- When You Were Young, Matchbook Romance- Monsters, Guns N Roses- Welcome to the Jungle, The Strokes- Reptilia, Disturbed- Stricken The Dead Kennedy’s- Holiday in Cambodia, Red Hot Chili Peppers- Suck My Kiss, Stevie Ray Vaughn- Pride and Joy, Social Distortion- Story of My Life, Bloc Party- Hellicopter, Sonic Youth- Kool Thing, Smashing Pumpkins- Cherub Rock

16 Santana- Black Magic Woman

15 Cream- Sunshine of Your Love

14 Rolling Stones- Paint It Black
14 ZZ Top- La Grange
14 Black Sabbath- Paranoid
14 Alice Cooper- School’s Out (+)

13 Aerosmith- Same Old Song and Dance
13 The Devil Went Down to Georgia
13 Weezer- My Name Is Jonas

12 Foghat- Slow Ride
12 Pearl Jam- Evenflow
12 Tenacious D- The Metal

11 The Who- The Seeker
11 Mountain- Mississippi Queen

10 Poison- Talk Dirty to Me
10 Pat Benatar- Hit Me With Your Best Shot
10 Scorpions- Rock You Like a Hurricane
10 Living Colour- Cult of Personality

9 Blue Oyster Cult- Cities on Flame with Rock and Roll

6 Slash- Guitar Battle
6 Iron Maiden- Number of the Beast (---)

3 Priestess- Lay Down


Rules:
(1) Add one point for your favorite song.
(2) Minus 3 Points for your least favorite song.
(3) 1 vote per person per hour.
(4) Copy and Paste these rules along with each vote.

ELIMINATED

Slayer- Raining blood, Kiss- Rock and Roll All Nite, DragonForce- Through The Fire and Flames, Beastie Boys - Sabotage, Queens of the Stone Age- 3’s and 7’s, Heart- Barracuda, Eric Johnson- Cliffs of Dover, In Flames - Take This Life, Rage Against the Machine- Bulls on Parade, AFI- Miss Murder, Muse- Knights of Cydonia, The Killers- When You Were Young, Matchbook Romance- Monsters, Guns N Roses- Welcome to the Jungle, The Strokes- Reptilia, Disturbed- Stricken The Dead Kennedy’s- Holiday in Cambodia, Red Hot Chili Peppers- Suck My Kiss, Stevie Ray Vaughn- Pride and Joy, Social Distortion- Story of My Life, Bloc Party- Hellicopter, Sonic Youth- Kool Thing, Smashing Pumpkins- Cherub Rock

16 Santana- Black Magic Woman

15 Alice Cooper- School’s Out (+)
15 Cream- Sunshine of Your Love

14 Rolling Stones- Paint It Black
14 ZZ Top- La Grange
14 Black Sabbath- Paranoid

13 Aerosmith- Same Old Song and Dance
13 The Devil Went Down to Georgia
13 Weezer- My Name Is Jonas

12 Foghat- Slow Ride
12 Pearl Jam- Evenflow
12 Tenacious D- The Metal

11 The Who- The Seeker
11 Mountain- Mississippi Queen

10 Poison- Talk Dirty to Me
10 Pat Benatar- Hit Me With Your Best Shot
10 Scorpions- Rock You Like a Hurricane
10 Living Colour- Cult of Personality

9 Blue Oyster Cult- Cities on Flame with Rock and Roll

6 Slash- Guitar Battle
3 Iron Maiden- Number of the Beast (---)

3 Priestess- Lay Down


Rules:
(1) Add one point for your favorite song.
(2) Minus 3 Points for your least favorite song.
(3) 1 vote per person per hour.
(4) Copy and Paste these rules along with each vote.

ELIMINATED

Slayer- Raining blood, Kiss- Rock and Roll All Nite, DragonForce- Through The Fire and Flames, Beastie Boys - Sabotage, Queens of the Stone Age- 3’s and 7’s, Heart- Barracuda, Eric Johnson- Cliffs of Dover, In Flames - Take This Life, Rage Against the Machine- Bulls on Parade, AFI- Miss Murder, Muse- Knights of Cydonia, The Killers- When You Were Young, Matchbook Romance- Monsters, Guns N Roses- Welcome to the Jungle, The Strokes- Reptilia, Disturbed- Stricken The Dead Kennedy’s- Holiday in Cambodia, Red Hot Chili Peppers- Suck My Kiss, Stevie Ray Vaughn- Pride and Joy, Social Distortion- Story of My Life, Bloc Party- Hellicopter, Sonic Youth- Kool Thing, Smashing Pumpkins- Cherub Rock

16 Santana- Black Magic Woman
16 Alice Cooper- School’s Out (+)

15 Cream- Sunshine of Your Love

14 Rolling Stones- Paint It Black
14 ZZ Top- La Grange
14 Black Sabbath- Paranoid

13 Aerosmith- Same Old Song and Dance
13 The Devil Went Down to Georgia
13 Weezer- My Name Is Jonas

12 Foghat- Slow Ride
12 Pearl Jam- Evenflow
12 Tenacious D- The Metal

11 The Who- The Seeker
11 Mountain- Mississippi Queen

10 Poison- Talk Dirty to Me
10 Pat Benatar- Hit Me With Your Best Shot
10 Scorpions- Rock You Like a Hurricane
10 Living Colour- Cult of Personality

9 Blue Oyster Cult- Cities on Flame with Rock and Roll

6 Slash- Guitar Battle

3 Priestess- Lay Down

0 Iron Maiden- Number of the Beast (---)

Rules:
(1) Add one point for your favorite song.
(2) Minus 3 Points for your least favorite song.
(3) 1 vote per person per hour.
(4) Copy and Paste these rules along with each vote.

ELIMINATED

Slayer- Raining blood, Kiss- Rock and Roll All Nite, DragonForce- Through The Fire and Flames, Beastie Boys - Sabotage, Queens of the Stone Age- 3’s and 7’s, Heart- Barracuda, Eric Johnson- Cliffs of Dover, In Flames - Take This Life, Rage Against the Machine- Bulls on Parade, AFI- Miss Murder, Muse- Knights of Cydonia, The Killers- When You Were Young, Matchbook Romance- Monsters, Guns N Roses- Welcome to the Jungle, The Strokes- Reptilia, Disturbed- Stricken The Dead Kennedy’s- Holiday in Cambodia, Red Hot Chili Peppers- Suck My Kiss, Stevie Ray Vaughn- Pride and Joy, Social Distortion- Story of My Life, Bloc Party- Hellicopter, Sonic Youth- Kool Thing, Smashing Pumpkins- Cherub Rock, Iron Maiden- Number of the Beast