Ok, you have no reason to believe I am town. Who cares then? I certainly don't. Come back when you have something more. Love how you're trying to push with 'why did you only talk about these guys' as if continuing to press is going to magically make your original question have purpose. What a poor follow-up.

Like, seriously mantle? Why didn't I talk about others? Did you forget that I just said that it was too cold and that I was waiting in line, ON MY PHONE? I'm happy I was even able to catch up and get a couple reads, much less post anything.

I'm being vague? umm sure whatever mantle. Please, add hypocrite to your list of poorly founded accusations against me.

I specifically said in both the original post and in this followup, that I can see DT is 'thinking'. When I see people genuinely thinking, it makes me think town. When I see people just talking bullshit, like meta, and theorizing pezus' probabilities for including x and y characters, I think scum. DT not only thought about the meta, but thought 'hmm there are three capn's. People suspect something. I don't see how it's that suspicious. Who's right? Me or them? Well, sure, it's strange that there are three, but maybe there are more groups that we just don't know about.' That's what I think when I read his post. That says town to me. While a scum mind could take the opportunity to make himself seem like town by downplaying, we can all see the overwhelming advantage of what that three person group suspicion lead to, evidenced by the vigilante himself. TALKING ABOUT THAT TEAM CAUSED A PLAYER TO BE KILLED. Do you see how meta gaming is scummy? Do you see why a mafia DT would actually encourage it rather than downplaying it? No? I don't expect you to.

Just qouting you to ask what's your take on this wjole situation. It's good to get a pair if fresh eyes!!

Pezus, please send a warning to ninetailchris. He doesn't look like he is going to be participating much.

Still catching up.  I had lunch since my last posts so I'm only on Page 9.  Sorry, but I think I'd prefer to continue to take things in in order rather than skipping to the last couple pages, because it gives better context and I don't even really know what you mean by "this whole situation".  I did skim it though to check for direct responses to what I already posted. 

I will say that I am suspicious of tabaha.  To me he seems ignorant.  But if ninetailschris or whoever is a complete absentee, we can't ignore that.  A modkill is the best way to deal with that, but if we're uncertain about getting it then Day 1 is the best time to spend a lynch on that kind of thing. 

Who would you consider Spiderman's sidekick?

Also, no, it doesn't mean anything if names were randomly assigned just like roles. I have already stated this.

Didn't Batman have like a bunch of Robins?  For instance, in the animated series, there's the old Robin who became Nighthawk and then the new Robin, right?