From my calculations; I would expect the scum team to consist of DT, Tabaha, Hat. However I am not too sure of anyone of them except Tabaha.

I want to know exactly who else is suspicious of tabaha.

Vote : Tabaha

I wouldn't mind his lynch.

Regarding my previous HoS on linkz, I take it back - he was joking and he does that as town or scum. He does joke a bit when scum though- but ultimately not much of a tell imo.

So. What do you think about zero at the moment? Scum/town?

Statistically speaking you are probably right that one of the players after you is scum. It would seem from my earlier games, and my attempts at balancing for my one next round, that non-townies are about 1/3- 1/4 of the player population. 

As there are 4 players that have "come after you" as you so put it, one of them is probably scum. Adding to that scum players tend to put a bit of suspicion onto other players when they can you actually have a case. Not a very good one mind, but still a case. Better then any of the attempted flavour hunters do anyway.

For that reason

Unvote

Vote: Yoshiya 

Out of the 4 players on Zero at the moment, your posts have seemed kind of hollow. Adding in a couple of iffy posts you are my scumspect for the moment DS. 

Really? What do you feel about zero then? What if zero is scum; how good will that statistic be?

Nice to see I'm worthy of your calculations :P  

Couple of questions: 

1) Why Tabaha and Hat? I have my own reasons for one of them, but I'd like to know yours. 

2) Is your scumspicion on me because of me being MJ? 

Also- what about the other 2/3 players that are probably non-town**? Any other scumspects or are you just waiting for everyone to finally tag in?

**(Going from the 1/3-1/4 estimate I think it is likely there are 5/6 non-town. I think 7 is too many) 

No, it is not based on your role or anything.

As far as others are concerned; I am not sure. Maybe stefl and ninetailchris. No idea really. I hope ninetailchris participates and doesn't just lurk.

There is also that other hax guy. More participation needed from all of these.

If Zero is scum, then I still think there will be one player on there who is non-town. I obviously havent played a game this big before, so I wouldnt know. But I think a scumteam of 6 is way too big. So I'm suspecting at least one scum team and a third party (4 and 1).  Third party might even be another mafia (so 3 and 3). 

From the two games I've actually been scum, they tend to have a foot in every reasonable lynch. So thats what i'm looking out for at this early stage. 

If you disagree with me about the numbers bit, please say thuogh. As i said, I've never played in a game this big, so i don't know if the balancing is different. 

You think scum would try and paint suspicion on their own guys before it looked like there will be a lynch on day 1?

I'm not able to post a lot today since I'm on the road, but I'll try to later tonight