By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - General Discussion - Mafia Round 44 - Ghostbusters!

theprof00 on 05 August 2012
supermario128 said:
theprof00 said:

1. Right. Mafia wouldn't. But you'd vote for him. Is my question still crazy?

2. What do you mean? There's the whole deniability by saying you claimed as such simply to out the real miller, thus protecting him. Did you not get my meaning there?

3. I would not, because mafia would never counterclaim miller. I would have a discussion, but I wouldn't vote him because I would think it's someone testing my claim.

How are you not getting this?

I didn't only say mafia wouldn't. I said no one would, so yes, still crazy.

I got it, but there is a bit of a difference. You would almost have to be unlynchable for that to work like Baalz last game. If you claim miller, only to have the real miller show up people will just think you are mafia "trying" to fake claim miller. You can say what you want after that, but your lynch will be inevitable.

That is where you and me differ. I don't think anyone would counter claim miller except for the actual miller himself. It isn't that hard to understand.

While your logic is infallible, be more careful when you play games with me, because had I not been implying LD, I would have surely claimed miller, just as I was wondering a few minutes ago whether I might've been able to get away with claiming miller and directly testing you. Do you not remember? I have nothing to lose.



Around the Network
theprof00 on 05 August 2012

How did you come to believe that wiibox is a VT, mario?



theprof00 on 05 August 2012

Stefl, I would propose that you are the only vanilla townie in this game. How do you respond to that?



supermario128 on 05 August 2012
theprof00 said:

But then why do you say "who first, Baalz or Pezus?" You suspected FF yesterday, you suspect him today. There are two people who voted me, both are on your list. Unless you think one of those two isn't mafia, you think all 3 are mafia, right? If you don't, why take the risk of Baalz or Pezus when you have FF?

Pezus and Baalz voting for you right away looked very suspicious to me. FF did no such thing. Are you saying you would rather have me vote for FF over the others? Like I said, I'm fine with any of the three. It doesn't matter which.




Nintendo still doomed?
Feel free to add me on 3DS or Switch! (PM me if you do ^-^)
Nintendo ID: Mako91                  3DS code: 4167-4543-6089

theprof00 on 05 August 2012
supermario128 said:
theprof00 said:

But then why do you say "who first, Baalz or Pezus?" You suspected FF yesterday, you suspect him today. There are two people who voted me, both are on your list. Unless you think one of those two isn't mafia, you think all 3 are mafia, right? If you don't, why take the risk of Baalz or Pezus when you have FF?

Pezus and Baalz voting for you right away looked very suspicious to me. FF did no such thing. Are you saying you would rather have me vote for FF over the others? Like I said, I'm fine with any of the three. It doesn't matter which.

OK, good.

What do you think of stefl?



Around the Network
supermario128 on 05 August 2012
theprof00 said:
How did you come to believe that wiibox is a VT, mario?

Based on his lack of interest in the game. In his first game where he was mafia and had a "cool" role he put in effort and was pretty active. It is hard to be mafia your first time playing, but he pulled it off. I'd imagine he is either a vanilla townie or some other role that doesn't do much. I'd like to hear from him to be sure though.




Nintendo still doomed?
Feel free to add me on 3DS or Switch! (PM me if you do ^-^)
Nintendo ID: Mako91                  3DS code: 4167-4543-6089

theprof00 on 05 August 2012
supermario128 said:
theprof00 said:
How did you come to believe that wiibox is a VT, mario?

Based on his lack of interest in the game. In his first game where he was mafia and had a "cool" role he put in effort and was pretty active. It is hard to be mafia your first time playing, but he pulled it off. I'd imagine he is either a vanilla townie or some other role that doesn't do much. I'd like to hear from him to be sure though.

That won't be necessary.



supermario128 on 05 August 2012
theprof00 said:

OK, good.

What do you think of stefl?

I believe his vanilla townie claim for now. If we can't decide whether Linkz scanned Nen or Stefl, even though I think it was Nen, then neither should be considered for a lynch. I believe Nen is pro town based on his play already. Like I said before, it is easy to tell when he is mafia. Stefl's lack of interest does go along with his vanilla claim, like Linkz pointed out before. I would like to see him contribute more though to be sure. Even if he is vanilla, that is no excuse.




Nintendo still doomed?
Feel free to add me on 3DS or Switch! (PM me if you do ^-^)
Nintendo ID: Mako91                  3DS code: 4167-4543-6089

theprof00 on 05 August 2012
supermario128 said:
theprof00 said:

But then why do you say "who first, Baalz or Pezus?" You suspected FF yesterday, you suspect him today. There are two people who voted me, both are on your list. Unless you think one of those two isn't mafia, you think all 3 are mafia, right? If you don't, why take the risk of Baalz or Pezus when you have FF?

Pezus and Baalz voting for you right away looked very suspicious to me. FF did no such thing. Are you saying you would rather have me vote for FF over the others? Like I said, I'm fine with any of the three. It doesn't matter which.

Perhaps you just didn't notice it, but the case against me was an orgy of evidence (see: minority report). The people believing me to be mafia are simply people reacting normally, imo. Mafia would never put down the first votes, imo.



theprof00 on 05 August 2012
supermario128 said:
theprof00 said:

OK, good.

What do you think of stefl?

I believe his vanilla townie claim for now. If we can't decide whether Linkz scanned Nen or Stefl, even though I think it was Nen, then neither should be considered for a lynch. I believe Nen is pro town based on his play already. Like I said before, it is easy to tell when he is mafia. Stefl's lack of interest does go along with his vanilla claim, like Linkz pointed out before. I would like to see him contribute more though to be sure. Even if he is vanilla, that is no excuse.

I don't believe there are any vanillas here.