I'm going to go as far as saying stefl was definitely NOT his read. He didn't mention him almost the entirety of day 2, but did take opporunities to point out nen was "very likely".

Thanks for pointing that out, though I'd have liked you to continue that suspicion today when FF was mentioned by pezus.

Anyhoo, no reason not to trust you on this.

If I could vote, I'd place it on FF.

He wouldn't, which is why I said NO ONE will counter claim me.

Yup, because I would love to get myself lynched on day one by exposing myself as a fake.

You, as miller, would not vote for someone who also said they were miller. The thought of that is laughable.

http://gamrconnect.vgchartz.com/post.php?id=4710076

I already mentioned Final Fan...

Honestly, I am comfortable with Baalz, Pezus, or FF. You (Prof) would be my 4th option.

1. Right. Mafia wouldn't. But you'd vote for him. Is my question still crazy?

2. What do you mean? There's the whole deniability by saying you claimed as such simply to out the real miller, thus protecting him. Did you not get my meaning there?

3. I would not, because mafia would never counterclaim miller. I would have a discussion, but I wouldn't vote him because I would think it's someone testing my claim.

How are you not getting this?

Sounds a lot like me last game...

But then why do you say "who first, Baalz or Pezus?" You suspected FF yesterday, you suspect him today. There are two people who voted me, both are on your list. Unless you think one of those two isn't mafia, you think all 3 are mafia, right? If you don't, why take the risk of Baalz or Pezus when you have FF?

Don't worry, as much as I've come to respect your play since our first game, I'm quite above copying others for my strategies tyvm.

I didn't only say mafia wouldn't. I said no one would, so yes, still crazy.

I got it, but there is a bit of a difference. You would almost have to be unlynchable for that to work like Baalz last game. If you claim miller, only to have the real miller show up people will just think you are mafia "trying" to fake claim miller. You can say what you want after that, but your lynch will be inevitable.

That is where you and me differ. I don't think anyone would counter claim miller except for the actual miller himself. It isn't that hard to understand.