Linkzmax said:
Baalzamon said:
pezus said:
theprof00 said:
This is why I removed my vote immediately at the beginning. I wasn't paying attention and joke voted. Thankfully day hadn't started yet. |
Interesting prof. It is all so convenient, isn't it? Your votes have consequences, eh... might it be that you said that so we would not push you to vote for someone? What about linkz post about voteless being very unbalanced for this particular game?
|
Well, in all reality Linkz point wasn't that strong. With an odd # of players, it takes the same to vote somebody out but due to the rules, with an even number of players, it actually takes 1 less vote than a normal game to vote somebody out. Contrary to what you are saying, some sort of limited voting role or something of that sort could easily seem plausible in this game.
|
You are right about there being no difference in the event of there being an even number of players; however, it does make a difference for an odd amount. Say there's 4 townies and 3 mafia. Because of prof, town could never get the majority needed for a lynch. As such mylo/lylo is earlier than in a normal game.
Fact of the matter is that on a normal day without any claims being revealed, majority lynches are very rare. Town is generally inactive and don't usually come to a consensus. Throwing in a voteless makes reaching a majority that much more of an obstacle.
Furthermore, thinking that there are 4 mafia or mafia can recruit IS more of a reason not to believe the claim. That gives scum even more control over the day.
|
Let me interrupt, because this is slightly different from what you said earlier.
You said that ESPECIALLY in this game where it only takes 50% to vote, voteless is imba. However, here you say that it's imba because it allows for lylo at a shorter time. The latter is a normal consequence of majority voting, but you specifically said it was imba because of the 50%.
@ your furthermore, I wasn't think that there is 4 mafia or that mafia can recruit. I said that people who think my role is entirely imbalanced makes me think they know something I don't, because voteless in a game where town outnumbers mafia standard 3v1 by 2 extra people makes complete sense for a voteless, and even a siblings on top of it. It would still be balanced. My problem is with people (you and nen) saying it's still imbalanced, which makes me think mafia is stronger than that because you're mafia and you know the distribution of number and roles.
Again, I do not think mafia starts with 4, or can become 4. I think that people who say 3 mafia is imbalanced with a voteless townie know something I don't.
Furthermore, I'm still voteless if there are 3 mafia or 4. I can't change my role, so keep thinking it's imbalanced, otherwise maybe you're facing a stronger powered town than you previously thought? Just throwing that out there.
