So tell me this.  As a mafia, would you kill somebody, knowing their role comes up as guilty to a cop?  (The answer is no).

Now, as a townie, lets say there are 3 people remaining in the game.  You have yourself, an admitted miller, and another person.  Would you rather vote out the other person, hoping that they are mafia, or vote out the person who told everybody if he was scanned by a cop, he would come up as guilty? (Unless there is some overwhelming evidence against the other person, the miller is almost always going to get lynched in a game)

If he was mafia, he'd be replaced without question, right?

If it came to that point, I would agree. But if he turned out to really be a miller you would loose the game. I can understand killing a miller somewhere into the game, but not in the first day or two.

But then again, Mario could just be trying to trick us like he did last game, by saying he was a pro-town janitor.

EBWOP. But I doubt he would use the same trick two days in a row.

Stop trying to meta! Especially horrible meta.

Mafia could have several reasons to kill a claimed miller.

I vote for the player who is scummiest. Claiming to scan guilty does not scum a player make. Gone are the days of "we need to lynch the miller claim just because."

Now if a cop never claims or flips and it's getting down to the wire, then yes mario must be lynched at that point. Til then he should be judged on his play just like everyone else.

For the SAK playerslot, I'm hopeful for a replace, because regardless of aignment modkills suck. No point in a wasted vote on him anymore.

Unvote: SAK

This feels like such a bad post to me. Not the No Lynch vote, but the comment about Wiibox. At that point, Wiibox voted pezus for acting normal and then spurge for his choices in TV shows. Either horrible logic for both or just joking around.(Fairly certain he admitted the later but it's no matter either way)

At that point it was too early to tell, but I do think Wiibox to be town now. So why would you give an undeserved compliment to an unproven townie?
Methinks it's because Wiiboxis not yet a high priority night kill target, so you tossed that little pat on the back to coax him into your pocket a bit.

And while I don't doubt you are/were on vacation, I don't like the excuse when there wasn't much change from your usual level of activity.

Oh AAAAND avoiding any stance on the mantle/spurge topic, instead giving a vagueness about mario due to his comments on the topic.

I thought I had commented on it? I remember saying that mantle was overreacting and that spurge was in the unusual position of being the reasonable one.

As for Wiibox, I was just pleased that he was participating coherently. I had set a really low bar because to me he was a "nobody" like all the other fresh meat that we can barely get to play the damn game, let alone play it well.

Hey Radish, give me your best guesses on who the mafia is.