supermario128 said:
|
And why is that?
supermario128 said:
|
And why is that?
mantlepiecek said: And why is that? |
Not sure. It just seems like you are trying to distant yourself from Nen in the event one of you flips scum.
As for my suspects. Right now my main suspect is Stefl. Like I said, I don't buy his vanilla claim. I would like to hear from Nen, Stefl, and Wiibox before discussing my other suspects any further.
Nintendo still doomed?
Feel free to add me on 3DS or Switch! (PM me if you do ^-^)
Nintendo ID: Mako91 3DS code: 4167-4543-6089
mantlepiecek said:
So what do you think I should have done? |
Prof, no answer?
spurgeonryan said: Yest, you have not managed to follow anyone and you picked a role that is not too big just when the heat was finally building up. Not everyone can be town mantle! I think you waited to long to play your cards. Like I said. If stefl, noctis and wii box are scum then that is bullshit because they have hardly been here. Nen, mantle and if there is another maybe stefl. |
I am alive all thanks to my hidden role. Expect me to be dead tonight. I can literally find out if someone has killed someone, in that sense it is a powerful role, I will be their target for sure.
"A role that is not too big", yeah right.
mantlepiecek said:
Prof, no answer? |
Not sure you're looking for an answer. I've proposed that your "hidden role" really hasn't done squat, and the times you have learned something it doesn't seem to have affected your judgements at all. Discreditting Linkz assessments, still including stefl in your suspect list, albeit at the end.....for the latter, why didn't you just scan someone else? Like spurge, or myself? Yeah, why didn't you scan me when you actually seemed to be suspecting me at some points?
Anyway, to answer, you can simply say, "prof, I know it seems weird, but Linkz is a good player with an ability to see things others might not. Like, what if he and nen are masons? I think at this point in the game, Linkz should be trusted. Later on, if he's still alive, then we can take another look, but for right now I'd go with trusting him. He just doesn't feel scummy to me." Or something of that nature.
Look, it doesn't matter that you didn't know he was the cop. You did nothing to assure everyone that Linkz should be trusted. No, the opposite...you actually undermined his assessment of nen. Sure, maybe you know nen is scum and so are sure he didn't scan nen. Otherwise, I don't see how you can say you don't understand why he's clearing nen when you know he's investigative.
I just don't understand how you can undermine Linkz clearing nen with the understanding that he's investigative. Am I supposed to understand that you just didn't know how to approach it? Sorry, I don't buy that. I also don't buy that you were subtly trying to ask linkz if nen was actually the cleared person, not to mention that you never weighed in with who you thought linkz visited, despite being right there with a very good lead. SHouldn't you have at least said "I think he visited stefl", or something, if you doubted it was nen?
theprof00 said:
Not sure you're looking for an answer. I've proposed that your "hidden role" really hasn't done squat, and the times you have learned something it doesn't seem to have affected your judgements at all. Discreditting Linkz assessments, still including stefl in your suspect list, albeit at the end.....for the latter, why didn't you just scan someone else? Like spurge, or myself? Yeah, why didn't you scan me when you actually seemed to be suspecting me at some points? Anyway, to answer, you can simply say, "prof, I know it seems weird, but Linkz is a good player with an ability to see things others might not. Like, what if he and nen are masons? I think at this point in the game, Linkz should be trusted. Later on, if he's still alive, then we can take another look, but for right now I'd go with trusting him. He just doesn't feel scummy to me." Or something of that nature. Look, it doesn't matter that you didn't know he was the cop. You did nothing to assure everyone that Linkz should be trusted. No, the opposite...you actually undermined his assessment of nen. Sure, maybe you know nen is scum and so are sure he didn't scan nen. Otherwise, I don't see how you can say you don't understand why he's clearing nen when you know he's investigative. I just don't understand how you can undermine Linkz clearing nen with the understanding that he's investigative. Am I supposed to understand that you just didn't know how to approach it? Sorry, I don't buy that. I also don't buy that you were subtly trying to ask linkz if nen was actually the cleared person, not to mention that you never weighed in with who you thought linkz visited, despite being right there with a very good lead. SHouldn't you have at least said "I think he visited stefl", or something, if you doubted it was nen? |
I was thinking of following you but you stumped yourself.
And I didn't discredit Linkz's assessment. Linkz said things that pointed at him being NOT the cop. Did you not see it?
I will remember what you said, but I will point out that I did indeed try and help linkz out. I did say he was looking like town all the time to help him in his argument.
Although remember that investigative roles can also mean scum role cops and scum flavour cops. I can't go around being 100% sure of linkz just because I got an investigative inspection.
I didn't undermine his assessment of Nen as much as you think. If I was any more obvious I might as well have role-claimed.
So tell me prof, why is it that after linkz flipped cop, you yourself didn't know exactly whom he targeted? Nen/stefl? It's because it wasn't that clear and I am not sure why you think it was so clear linkz being sure of Nen. The only difference between me and you is that you knew he was investigative a bit later, on day 3. Whereas I knew it on day 2.
And a follower's inspection means nothing. I felt my best attempt was following stefl because now I can actually act a Lie Detector.
http://gamrconnect.vgchartz.com/post.php?id=4699210
Linkzmax on 29 July 2012
You didn't? radish must have said what he did for nothing then. Well since I think you're scum this list of yours is probably bull, but if you are town then you're merely wrong. Nothing to worry about. You have no idea how cool I feel right now. Just like yesterday, I feel that Wiibox, spurge, and mantle are all town. Less certain, but leaning town with pezus too. And I have enough reason to believe others are also town. What was my intent then, prof? |
Well, I don't know what happened with that post, but if you click the link you will know.