By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - General Discussion - Mafia Round 44 - Ghostbusters!

mantlepiecek said:
I am the Follower. It works like a tracker, but I can't see who someone targeted. I can know the action the guy performed that night.


Sorry I miss this one.



Around the Network
mantlepiecek said:

I don't like Linkz's surety of Nen being town, honestly can't see why he thinks Nen is town with such surety. I still feel he is town, just overconfident maybe.

However I also can't see why prof thinks Nen is sure scum either. Yeah he didn't answer the mafia question but I think a lot of us did think of it as a joke in the first place. There are some other parameters prof has mentioned, but I don't think those imply that Nen is scum.

Baalz vs Mario case is interesting. Honestly I don't see Mario being scum other than the situation prof gave : that scum can recruit. But I don't think that they would be this powerful in such a small game. If scum can recruit then the first person they will would be prof (if he is town). And NOT mario. Having someone like prof would be a bonus, no?

Recruiting mario wouldn't make much sense really.

So then what's the bolded about?



I want to hear Nen's role claim and hear from Wiibox and Stefl before I make my vote. No point in rushing things.




Nintendo still doomed?
Feel free to add me on 3DS or Switch! (PM me if you do ^-^)
Nintendo ID: Mako91                  3DS code: 4167-4543-6089

Stefl claiming vanilla made you follow him?
You just gave up your teammate mantle.



Prof can you please vote right now? Anyone will do.



Around the Network
theprof00 said:
mantlepiecek said:

I don't like Linkz's surety of Nen being town, honestly can't see why he thinks Nen is town with such surety. I still feel he is town, just overconfident maybe.

However I also can't see why prof thinks Nen is sure scum either. Yeah he didn't answer the mafia question but I think a lot of us did think of it as a joke in the first place. There are some other parameters prof has mentioned, but I don't think those imply that Nen is scum.

Baalz vs Mario case is interesting. Honestly I don't see Mario being scum other than the situation prof gave : that scum can recruit. But I don't think that they would be this powerful in such a small game. If scum can recruit then the first person they will would be prof (if he is town). And NOT mario. Having someone like prof would be a bonus, no?

Recruiting mario wouldn't make much sense really.

So then what's the bolded about?

It doesn't tell me who Linkz visited prof.

This is why I asked him this indirectly. He didn't answer, and said that he will carry the shame if he is wrong.

Makes me think he didn't investigate Nen.



theprof00 said:
Stefl claiming vanilla made you follow him?
You just gave up your teammate mantle.

Stefl claimed vanilla. I wanted to test his claim.

So yes, I did follow him.



mantlepiecek said:
theprof00 said:
mantlepiecek said:

I don't like Linkz's surety of Nen being town, honestly can't see why he thinks Nen is town with such surety. I still feel he is town, just overconfident maybe.

However I also can't see why prof thinks Nen is sure scum either. Yeah he didn't answer the mafia question but I think a lot of us did think of it as a joke in the first place. There are some other parameters prof has mentioned, but I don't think those imply that Nen is scum.

Baalz vs Mario case is interesting. Honestly I don't see Mario being scum other than the situation prof gave : that scum can recruit. But I don't think that they would be this powerful in such a small game. If scum can recruit then the first person they will would be prof (if he is town). And NOT mario. Having someone like prof would be a bonus, no?

Recruiting mario wouldn't make much sense really.

So then what's the bolded about?

It doesn't tell me who Linkz visited prof.

This is why I asked him this indirectly. He didn't answer, and said that he will carry the shame if he is wrong.

Makes me think he didn't investigate Nen.

No, you said "I cannot see why Linkz think Nen is town with such surety". Knowing that he is a cop, you should have been able to put two and two together. In fact, most of the arguing done on that day could have totally been avoided.

You even threw doubt on his claim by saying "What's with you, Linkz and 95%? And no, it's not that easy to tell when nen is scum. He was serial killer and it only came to light later on."

You said you wanted to check stefl's claim. Why didn't you check Mario's?



You also wrote this yesterDay
"Out of all of you I feel wonk is the scummiest btw. Then Nen, prof, mario and stefl."

So you still thought stefl was mafia after visiting him?

Tell me, did you role really tell you anything? It seems like you've not used the information it's given you a single time in game.



theprof00 said:
mantlepiecek said:
theprof00 said:
mantlepiecek said:

I don't like Linkz's surety of Nen being town, honestly can't see why he thinks Nen is town with such surety. I still feel he is town, just overconfident maybe.

However I also can't see why prof thinks Nen is sure scum either. Yeah he didn't answer the mafia question but I think a lot of us did think of it as a joke in the first place. There are some other parameters prof has mentioned, but I don't think those imply that Nen is scum.

Baalz vs Mario case is interesting. Honestly I don't see Mario being scum other than the situation prof gave : that scum can recruit. But I don't think that they would be this powerful in such a small game. If scum can recruit then the first person they will would be prof (if he is town). And NOT mario. Having someone like prof would be a bonus, no?

Recruiting mario wouldn't make much sense really.

So then what's the bolded about?

It doesn't tell me who Linkz visited prof.

This is why I asked him this indirectly. He didn't answer, and said that he will carry the shame if he is wrong.

Makes me think he didn't investigate Nen.

No, you said "I cannot see why Linkz think Nen is town with such surety". Knowing that he is a cop, you should have been able to put two and two together. In fact, most of the arguing done on that day could have totally been avoided.

You even threw doubt on his claim by saying "What's with you, Linkz and 95%? And no, it's not that easy to tell when nen is scum. He was serial killer and it only came to light later on."

You said you wanted to check stefl's claim. Why didn't you check Mario's?

Unlike mario, stefl claimed pure vanilla. Unlike mario, stefl was being inactive. Unlike mario, stefl was being lynched and I wanted to find out if stefl was lying. Following mario wouldn't have told me if stefl was lying.

You forget that "investigative role" can mean anything. I am an investigative role myself.

When I said what's with you, linkz and 95%, I meant it was funny that both of them used the same no. as the percentage of being sure of Nen.

It wasn't me putting doubt on his claim.