No meta needed at all. The reason why I defended mantle and went after wonk and nen is because they FIT the profile of players who were trying to lynch others based on faulty evidence, among other things. The reason I defended mantle is because his posts made sense. He was smart, logical, and concise.
However, I mis-read the game completely by assuming that mafia would be these kinds of players. No. This game, it is players being quiet and logical, avoiding discussion, but only making logical conclusions with no real weight behind any of their accusations.
For that reason, we should at least look at mantle, and then another afterwards, maybe stefl. Most importantly, we need to get these guys talking.