1) So you are saying I should just believe people when they say something? Trucks case was very strong, he accused of baalzamon of something that seemed like a very weird reason. It almost felt artificial which is why I pushed on him to reveal his suspects.

2) Yeah, I attacked TOS because I don't accept stuff just because someone said it.

3) I asked who TOS found innocent because I thought we could cross off people from our list of suspects. But then, thanks to something I did a day before, I thought it might be unneeded. Trucks revealing his info is not required which is why I didn't push for it.

If you see my first post of day 2, you will remember that I was suspicious of someone? What if trucks had investigated that guy and he turned out to be innocent? It would have saved us a lot of unnecessary confusion.

It was a nice try, but you seem to have forgotten your facts outlaw.

I don't think you understand my point, which may be my fault, so let me be more explicit. 

If someone is power, they usually want to use that power without drawing undue attention from the mafia.  That's why many players tend to play cautiously and even lurk when they're the doctor.  So it follows that someone wanting to get by and use their power as much as possible before the mafia go after them might be less than happy about a TOS stamp of approval, AKA huge flaming bullseye. 

You may disagree that TOS's silence is best for town despite that point -- Linkz does. 

Please explain?  You are inferring you watched him, but just earlier, you more or less stated your role was something else (unless I completely misinterpret what you are saying, in which case, please entertain me as to what this does mean).

This is a power heavy game so I don't think someone being "confirmed" by ToS would put someone much more at risk than all these players claiming like crazy this game.

Yes some people like to play on the edge when they are a power but that can lead to the town not believing them when they do finally claim. ToS holding back also could easily be scum bying time.

If this was a low poered game yes it would make sence for ToS to keep quiet on town scans until the doc shows up or he has a good amount of townies he can confirm.

1.  It has nothing to do with believing or disbelieving TOS's claim, it has to do with why did you immediately ask for a suspect list from someone who just claimed cop?  I don't see why you would want to do that.  (See my above post for details.) 

I'd complain but I will be heading out of town myself.

Because I didn't believe his claims at first. Anybody can claim "I am the cop". I thought cross-questioning him might help us.

If you observe I asked that same question to a lot of people to get their point of view on where others stand. It's got nothing to do with trucks being a cop.

Ultimately, it shouldn't matter at all, because

1) We still don't know who he investigated.

2) We still don't know for sure if he told the truth today. Although personally, I think he is.

3) And nobody is in any danger. Except for the ones that roleclaimed.

I am very surprised at ninpie roleclaiming this early. In my opinion he should have waited.

No I was not inferring that at all, but I'm quite interested in what you think I seem to be saying. Granted, saying it out in the open doesn't appear as shady as not commenting about it at all. For instance, only scum pretend to not have seen a claim.

I remembered yesterday that Rol also mentioned fire, so I went back and re-read it.

He was referencing pandoras tower, and mentioned the word "antidote". However, in reference to outlaw, Rol mentioned, burned,poisoned, and paralyzed.

Now, I find there are two possible options.

A) Outlaw is the anti-janitor.
B) Outlaw is pretending to be the anti-janitor.

Can you post a link to that post?