By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Microsoft - Fable: The Journey Kinect criticism unfair say Fable's creators, If you don't like it, don't buy it

Lafiel on 11 April 2012
TadpoleJackson said:
PullusPardus said:

Wait you asked him if had an xbox and now you are saying why does he care? you're the one who is caring if he had one or not.


He asked him if he has an Xbox, the poster said no, Kowenicki asks why he cares about an Xbox exclusive... I don't see the problem with it. Why would someone that doesn't own a 360 care about this game?

Turkish said he played Fable 2&3, so that clearly shows he is interested in the franchise (even if he doesn't own a 360 at the moment)



Around the Network
Dr.Grass on 11 April 2012
sales2099 said:
Dr.Grass said:
That was one of the lamest set of comments from a dev I've ever seen.

And the Mario analogies are TOTALLY not applicable here AT ALL. It makes no sense. I don't need to spell it out because only a retard wouldn't know why.

Apart from that, he has no right to bring Mario into this.

And who is he trying to appeal to with these comments?

-20% respect points.

I bet the reviews are going to hit 'em hard.

The Mario reference means that a established franchise has spinoffs. Mario spinoffs are ok but since this one is kinect based and not Fable 4 the game gets automatic hate. He was pointing out how unfair the criticism is and how ignorant it is.

Has no right? Its just an opinion. Dont act like he just insulted your religion. 

He is appealing to the gamer elite who think its trendy and cool to bash motion gaming, trying to tell them to wait and see, that the game might actually surprise them. 

Your final comment implying that due to these quotes, reviewers will give lower review scores. This isnt the user rated section on metacritic that is 95% emotion and 5% detached professional opinion. Reviewers will rate this game based on its inherent quality, not emotionally charged reviews based on someones opinion of their game. You can loose 100% respect for them for all I care, but that has no bearing on how good the game possibly is. Try to remember that. 

hogwash. All of it.



sales2099 on 12 April 2012
Dr.Grass said:
sales2099 said:
Dr.Grass said:
That was one of the lamest set of comments from a dev I've ever seen.

And the Mario analogies are TOTALLY not applicable here AT ALL. It makes no sense. I don't need to spell it out because only a retard wouldn't know why.

Apart from that, he has no right to bring Mario into this.

And who is he trying to appeal to with these comments?

-20% respect points.

I bet the reviews are going to hit 'em hard.

The Mario reference means that a established franchise has spinoffs. Mario spinoffs are ok but since this one is kinect based and not Fable 4 the game gets automatic hate. He was pointing out how unfair the criticism is and how ignorant it is.

Has no right? Its just an opinion. Dont act like he just insulted your religion. 

He is appealing to the gamer elite who think its trendy and cool to bash motion gaming, trying to tell them to wait and see, that the game might actually surprise them. 

Your final comment implying that due to these quotes, reviewers will give lower review scores. This isnt the user rated section on metacritic that is 95% emotion and 5% detached professional opinion. Reviewers will rate this game based on its inherent quality, not emotionally charged reviews based on someones opinion of their game. You can loose 100% respect for them for all I care, but that has no bearing on how good the game possibly is. Try to remember that. 

hogwash. All of it.

?

Not sure if sarcasm or an admission of defeat. oh well nm. I said my piece



Xbox: Best hardware, Game Pass best value, best BC, more 1st party genres and multiplayer titles. 

 

Dr.Grass on 12 April 2012
sales2099 said:
Dr.Grass said:
sales2099 said:
Dr.Grass said:
That was one of the lamest set of comments from a dev I've ever seen.

And the Mario analogies are TOTALLY not applicable here AT ALL. It makes no sense. I don't need to spell it out because only a retard wouldn't know why.

Apart from that, he has no right to bring Mario into this.

And who is he trying to appeal to with these comments?

-20% respect points.

I bet the reviews are going to hit 'em hard.

The Mario reference means that a established franchise has spinoffs. Mario spinoffs are ok but since this one is kinect based and not Fable 4 the game gets automatic hate. He was pointing out how unfair the criticism is and how ignorant it is.

Has no right? Its just an opinion. Dont act like he just insulted your religion. 

He is appealing to the gamer elite who think its trendy and cool to bash motion gaming, trying to tell them to wait and see, that the game might actually surprise them. 

Your final comment implying that due to these quotes, reviewers will give lower review scores. This isnt the user rated section on metacritic that is 95% emotion and 5% detached professional opinion. Reviewers will rate this game based on its inherent quality, not emotionally charged reviews based on someones opinion of their game. You can loose 100% respect for them for all I care, but that has no bearing on how good the game possibly is. Try to remember that. 

hogwash. All of it.

?

Not sure if sarcasm or an admission of defeat. oh well nm. I said my piece

Using the biggest icon in gaming to justify/explain decisions made with a below average IP is hogwash.

And the only worthwhile point you had...

''Your final comment implying that due to these quotes, reviewers will give lower review scores''

Would've only been worthwhile if the end product didn't suck. And it most probably will.



sales2099 on 20 April 2012
Dr.Grass said:
sales2099 said:
Dr.Grass said:
sales2099 said:
Dr.Grass said:
That was one of the lamest set of comments from a dev I've ever seen.

And the Mario analogies are TOTALLY not applicable here AT ALL. It makes no sense. I don't need to spell it out because only a retard wouldn't know why.

Apart from that, he has no right to bring Mario into this.

And who is he trying to appeal to with these comments?

-20% respect points.

I bet the reviews are going to hit 'em hard.

The Mario reference means that a established franchise has spinoffs. Mario spinoffs are ok but since this one is kinect based and not Fable 4 the game gets automatic hate. He was pointing out how unfair the criticism is and how ignorant it is.

Has no right? Its just an opinion. Dont act like he just insulted your religion. 

He is appealing to the gamer elite who think its trendy and cool to bash motion gaming, trying to tell them to wait and see, that the game might actually surprise them. 

Your final comment implying that due to these quotes, reviewers will give lower review scores. This isnt the user rated section on metacritic that is 95% emotion and 5% detached professional opinion. Reviewers will rate this game based on its inherent quality, not emotionally charged reviews based on someones opinion of their game. You can loose 100% respect for them for all I care, but that has no bearing on how good the game possibly is. Try to remember that. 

hogwash. All of it.

?

Not sure if sarcasm or an admission of defeat. oh well nm. I said my piece

Using the biggest icon in gaming to justify/explain decisions made with a below average IP is hogwash.

And the only worthwhile point you had...

''Your final comment implying that due to these quotes, reviewers will give lower review scores''

Would've only been worthwhile if the end product didn't suck. And it most probably will.

The icon isnt the point. Its the concept. IPs that sell millions get spinoffs. The example is justified. 

Your last sentence once again proves its trendy and hip to bash kinect just because its kinect. That is exactly the ignorance the origional quote is trying to address. 



Xbox: Best hardware, Game Pass best value, best BC, more 1st party genres and multiplayer titles.