By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Sony - Uncharted 3 Review Thread!

Tagged games:

Boutros said:
ArmGunar said:
I contact meta for this review ..

" Hello,

Before adding A.V Club's review of Uncharted 3 and others reviews, the average was 93,95, why did the website round to 93 although Batman Arkham City's average is 95,89 and you round to 96 ?

And why do you add the A.V Club's review of Uncharted 3 ?
The review is bad not because of the score but, the review is only a fews lines, the reviewer says anything without arguing ...
Moreover this website isn't specialized in video games and you add this review ?

I take for example, VGChartz which does reviews and that's a video game about website but you don't add their reviews ...

Or the review of the website " Jeuxvideo.com " which is the biggest website in France and has the most of visits in Europe ...
This website is the most influential in the francophone world including France, Quebec, Belgium, Luxembourg and many countries in Africa !

A.V Club hasn't got their place in metacritics although others websites deserve this place !

And a lot of gamers agree with me, we hope an answer and maybe you can remove the A.V. Club's review of Uncharted 3.

Thank you for reading. "

~ Metacritic's scores ("Metascores") are weighted averages—certain publications are given more significance "based on their stature." ~

thats right

and you guys should care about "GOTY/GOTY shooter"etc right now since it already 90+ in metacritic,don't need to care about unknow site



Around the Network

Hey guys;


SpikeTV is giving Goty award is based on what criteria? Because it loses the GOTY chance?



Sorry for English :/

Wow, avclub review says archaic controls but does not explain how they are archaic. Horrible review. Anyway my copy should be shipping in soon, but this guy is just trolling.



GoldPunch said:
Hey guys;


SpikeTV is giving Goty award is based on what criteria? Because it loses the GOTY chance?

Its based on the impact the game makes. Uncharted 3 is leading in that department so far I believe. IGN's 10/10 made people shit bricks XD.



can't wait for 10 december :)



Sorry for English :/

Around the Network

I think it's time I suspend my replay of Arkham City (New Game +) and begin my replay of Uncharted 2. I originally intended to replay 1 and 2 (like I replayed Gears 1 and 2 before Gears 3 and replayed Arkham Asylum before Arkham City) but damn. Good games have been hitting left and right!

That AV Club review is some bullshit (like that Gears 3 review that was like 65 or something) but I won't let it detract from enjoying one of my favorite series this gen. Only two days to go!!



the a.v. club uncharted review http://origin.avclub.com/articles/uncharted-3-drakes-deception,64220/



^_^ Bloodbath

Also, it is not a 5/10. Metacritic has always been messed up when it comes to A,B,C,D,E...
It is a 7.something I think.



I just read that review, man, Rol could have written that, it was very poorly made. Hell, I could have written it in 10 minutes.
And for those who are bashing Metacritic for adding it, they HAD to, it is on their system.



what a great review! only a few lines and it gets added to metacritic! great..