By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Sony - Uncharted 3 Review Thread!

Tagged games:

Andrespetmonkey said:
Came back after 2 hours, this thread fucking exploded. Greg miller gave it the 10!

Yeah and the place I hang ( gamereactor ) had both opinions being a 10/10, you have no idea how happy I was. GT als ogave their highest PS3 exclusive score ever.

 

See the meta though? >_> I totally called it, didnt i?



Around the Network

It'll get less than Uncharted 2 even though it's a superior game since Uncharted 2 wasn't nearly as expected, same will happen with rocksteadys next game.



94 with 29 Critics

9 perfect score

http://www.metacritic.com/game/playstation-3/uncharted-3-drakes-deception/

Meta need to put another two 10/10 reviews



FZ.Se gave it 5/5!



The_Joker_Product said:
ethomaz said:
The_Joker_Product said:
Doesnt look like this will be winning game of the year.

Why? The scores is better than every other game relesed this year.

No it isnt it has a metacritic of 93 so far. Batman AC has a 96, Portal 2 has a 95 Ocarina of Time 3DS has a 94. If anything Uncharted 3s score will only go down like they usually always do.

Batman AC have just 26 reviews for PS3... putting more reviews the score down like the 360 version.

Uncharted 3s score will go up with more 10/10 reviews.

94-95 is my prediction.



Around the Network

Don't really agree with the Eurogamer review personally. The score of 8 is fine and all but I just don't think what he complains about justifies it. When they review Skyrim and give it a 9.5 it will prove they don't really review based on quality.



Aldro said:
Andrespetmonkey said:
Came back after 2 hours, this thread fucking exploded. Greg miller gave it the 10!

Yeah and the place I hang ( gamereactor ) had both opinions being a 10/10, you have no idea how happy I was. GT als ogave their highest PS3 exclusive score ever.

 

See the meta though? >_> I totally called it, didnt i?

I know man, I already explained my theory post on here before this, but I'll say it again anyway, it's because uncharted 2 was so unexpected since the first game was seen as good but nothing special, now Uncharted 3 has insanely high expectations which it probably reached with most reviewers, but some reviewers were expecting an 11/10 or thought UC2 was over-rated and that influenced the UC3 score. Those are just 2 reasons relating to a predecessors success, there's more reasons than that. It happens time and time again, if a games predecessor is an unexpected hit, it's likely to be under-rated and almost guaranteed to get a lower metacritic. 93 (uc3 meta at the moment) is obviously incredible, but compare it to UC2s 96 and 39 100s and it loses meaning. 



dunno if this is already posted but

http://translate.google.com/translate?sl=it&tl=en&js=n&prev=_t&hl=en&ie=UTF-8&layout=2&eotf=1&u=http%3A%2F%2Fmultiplayer.it%2Frecensioni%2F94824-uncharted-3-linganno-di-drake-la-meravigliosa-avventura-di-drake.html&act=url

Multiplayer.it

97/100

"A few years ago ended a movie trilogy (later followed by polluted fourth episode), which has left its mark in the collective imagination with its rhythm, the sense of adventure, humor and the dream environment, graced by a Harrison Ford star performer along with a plethora of excellent actors. The spirit of Indiana Jones can be found without too much forcing the Uncharted series, which ideally has delivered these key points in the form of video game and adding the fun factor when you need to have the ability of the player to take on the events firsthand.

"The irony of the main protagonists, a rhythm and a very tight technical sector / have devoted exceptional artistic creation from Naughty Dog in the Olympus of the best productions of this gaming generation, particularly from first to second chapter has been a dramatic jump in terms of direction, graphic design and conduct of the action.

"Here we are talking about 3 Uncharted: Drake's deception so that the task is not easy to confirm the good things seen in the past and must be confronted by a predecessor, who still holds the earliest POSITION in many respects, not least Technical. The result? Beyond the vote that you can already see in this review, is explained here in the thousands of characters to follow.



In-Kat-We-Trust Brigade!

"This world is Merciless, and it's also very beautiful"

For All News/Info related to the PlayStation Vita, Come and join us in the Official PSV Thread!

Its 94 now based on 29!

Man, me and Andrespetmonkey are going to have one hell of a battle XD (see Sig).

Imagine if batman fell to 94, and Uncharted stayed there or climbed to 95.

Gotta give mad props if that happends! (wont probably though).



Wagram said:

Don't really agree with the Eurogamer review personally. The score of 8 is fine and all but I just don't think what he complains about justifies it. When they review Skyrim and give it a 9.5 it will prove they don't really review based on quality.

Yeah, it seemed his main complaint was it is too linear. That doesn't make sense, the game is supposed to be linear, it's almost trying to be, linear is only a bad thing if the game doesn't have a very strong narrative to guide it or if it's supposed to be an open game.