TruckOSaurus said: You're right that your post was much of the basis for my reply because it seemed you went out of your way to make two bad guy looks good so I'd be the only with a purely bad name. As for Baal, I'm not ready to lynch him yet. I have reasons to doubt the fact that you're unrestricted in your role but before I bring them forward. I kinda need to know what Baal really is. According to him, he's got an unimportant role and was happy to leave doctor rumors floating around him so he could take the hit for the real doc. If that's then he'll have no trouble roleclaiming and clearing up the situation. |
I didn't go out of my way. My only basis is the uncharted wiki, so aliegence are not as obvious to me as they are to you who played the games. You have the only character that I see as impossible to consider good, however, others here have played the game and will agree or not on whether FF's, hat's and baal's characters are candidates to being good or just bad.
I understand that it's hard to swallow a claim of unrestricted when every role seems restricted, that's why I took radish as an example when I tried to soft claim, because I read his role to have been both tracker and watcher (1 shot) last night and thus to have an extra like me... concluding that he too is unrestricted on his main ability. He has yet to comment on this, but I take silence as confirmation. Without claiming his full role, he could just like you say that he doubts i'm restricted. A rebutal would be odd, but that won't change my claim.
In any case, me being restricted or not changes noting to baal's guilt on the claim. And he didn't just let the rumors float, he embraced them and asked players to confirm him in this, it's to this proactive stance that I reacted not the rumors themselves, these were proff's not baal's.
OoOoOoOoOoOoOoOoOoOoOoOoOoOoOoOoOoOoOoOoOoOoOoO