By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - General Discussion - Mafia Round 32 - Harry Potter

Linkzmax said:

1. So you're countering my point by avoiding the conversation, as I said scum might do? I mean you do say you think it's pointless, but you're not really urging anyone away/towards someone.(Yes I see the vote on Wonk, but it reads as serious as my vote on prof day two was)

2. Were Soleron and Marcus both not online throughout the night? If so then it definitely confirms one of the two as town, and obviously both if there is indeed only a single mafia left.

I could get behind a John lynch also.

1. There's a difference between lurking and avoiding a conversation. Who am I to stop an argument? Just because I see something as pointless now doesn't mean it won't evolve into someone slipping up and outing himself. 

2. That's a possibility yeah(i'm guessing you worded it incorrectly on accident). But I've played several games with Soleron, and although he has lurking tendencies he has never been this bad with it. More than likely he abandoned the game. Especially since he has been on since Baalzamon poked him. Jackson seems like a newb that signed up and lost interest quickly. Now the same could be said about John, but he has shown up in the thread a couple times so he has been checking in, and the Silver tiger and FF kills make some sense if he were the only mafia member left. Otherwise I am completely clueless why those two...



Around the Network
TadpoleJackson said:
Linkzmax said:

1. So you're countering my point by avoiding the conversation, as I said scum might do? I mean you do say you think it's pointless, but you're not really urging anyone away/towards someone.(Yes I see the vote on Wonk, but it reads as serious as my vote on prof day two was)

2. Were Soleron and Marcus both not online throughout the night? If so then it definitely confirms one of the two as town, and obviously both if there is indeed only a single mafia left.

I could get behind a John lynch also.

1. There's a difference between lurking and avoiding a conversation. Who am I to stop an argument? Just because I see something as pointless now doesn't mean it won't evolve into someone slipping up and outing himself. 

2. That's a possibility yeah(i'm guessing you worded it incorrectly on accident). But I've played several games with Soleron, and although he has lurking tendencies he has never been this bad with it. More than likely he abandoned the game. Especially since he has been on since Baalzamon poked him. Jackson seems like a newb that signed up and lost interest quickly. Now the same could be said about John, but he has shown up in the thread a couple times so he has been checking in, and the Silver tiger and FF kills make some sense if he were the only mafia member left. Otherwise I am completely clueless why those two...

1. I wasn't accusing you of lurking, simply saying that if town is chasing its own tails then scum can sit back and let them destroy themselves. I'm not saying you should stop it either, but you are doing exactly what I said I was worried about. That is all

2. What is a possibility? I was assuming that your clearing of Marcus and Soleron meant that you knew they were not online during the night phase, and so would not have been able to send in a mafia kill.(Then again if Baal is acting like past mods, he could have allowed the kill by way of a quicktopic post) What did I word incorrectly? It is still possible, if two mafia remain, for one of those two to be scum and their partner just took action. Thus neither individual is cleared, but they can't both be scum, and so one of the two is confirmed town.



Linkzmax said:
theprof00 said:
Hmmm, what's REALLY going on here, I wonder.

Linkz completely missed something thinking that I was playing dumb.
And Heph says that wonk and my connection is mafia related, but the linkz connection is a falsified one.

I believe at least one of you is mafia.

What did I miss?

Care to explain your point on Heph?(and by that I mean what you're trying to say in this post, not a general case against him) I'd say it doesn't make sense, especially given your conclusion, but I could be understanding you wrong.

I was "suspecting" you back for that favor. Although mine was more subtle and believeable imo.

I just don't see how Heph can say me and wonk are together, but me and you aren't, or you and ff aren't. It really seems like insider info, as in both of you, (linkz and heph) are mafia. Maybe I just haven't thoroughly read what he's talking about enough, but it really just seems like (if he were town) relying on a coin toss. Then again, as town he usually says some pretty outlandish things, much like myself.

I'm willing to put an end to yo_john honestly. I think he should've been lynched then, and now he's proposing a no lynch.



Linkzmax said:

1. I wasn't accusing you of lurking, simply saying that if town is chasing its own tails then scum can sit back and let them destroy themselves. I'm not saying you should stop it either, but you are doing exactly what I said I was worried about. That is all

2. What is a possibility? I was assuming that your clearing of Marcus and Soleron meant that you knew they were not online during the night phase, and so would not have been able to send in a mafia kill.(Then again if Baal is acting like past mods, he could have allowed the kill by way of a quicktopic post) What did I word incorrectly? It is still possible, if two mafia remain, for one of those two to be scum and their partner just took action. Thus neither individual is cleared, but they can't both be scum, and so one of the two is confirmed town.

Haha, this is why I try no to post on little sleep. umm..

1. My mistake. I was putting words into your mouth 

2. Again, I seem to have misread this. I read it as "definitely confirms one of the two as scum". 

2.5. When I put "yeah, that's a possibility" i meant that they could have easily been lurking only appearing to make their night actions. If they in fact had any. But then i listed why I didn't think that was. No, I didn't confirm that they were offline at the time, and im sure you can find that marcus spammed up the forums in that time.

As of this time, August 24 0:34, I do not have any suspicioun of either Soleron or Jackson 



Might as well get the party started.
Unvote
Vote: Yo_john



Around the Network
theprof00 said:
Linkzmax said:
theprof00 said:
Hmmm, what's REALLY going on here, I wonder.

Linkz completely missed something thinking that I was playing dumb.
And Heph says that wonk and my connection is mafia related, but the linkz connection is a falsified one.

I believe at least one of you is mafia.

What did I miss?

Care to explain your point on Heph?(and by that I mean what you're trying to say in this post, not a general case against him) I'd say it doesn't make sense, especially given your conclusion, but I could be understanding you wrong.

I was "suspecting" you back for that favor. Although mine was more subtle and believeable imo.

I just don't see how Heph can say me and wonk are together, but me and you aren't, or you and ff aren't. It really seems like insider info, as in both of you, (linkz and heph) are mafia. Maybe I just haven't thoroughly read what he's talking about enough, but it really just seems like (if he were town) relying on a coin toss. Then again, as town he usually says some pretty outlandish things, much like myself.

I'm willing to put an end to yo_john honestly. I think he should've been lynched then, and now he's proposing a no lynch.

Oh, well then I didn't miss anything at all. That's what I was hoping you meant by it, but I really didn't see the need for it.

Heph is saying Wonk and I are the false connection due to Wonk making the direct connection to me but an indirect one to you. Your misunderstanding explains why I couldn't make sense of the point. Also he originally thought we(you and I) were together as scum, but that seems to have lessened due to Wonk.

It's a literal impossibility for FF and I to be scummates, since he's a dead townie and I'm a living townie. :P I'm guessing you meant Wonk there though.



I'm on board. At the very least the pressure should spark better participation. I would like to see he not exceed 3 votes though. I'd still like to hear from Wonk and Heph, and in the event Soleron is modkilled I don't want the instalynch. I know there will be warning if a modkill is to come, but none of us has a really good track record for presence this round.

Vote: yo_john117



I'm ok with lynching yo_john

glad to see more posts I'll give them proper response when I return.



theprof00 said:
Hephaestos said:
Wonktonodi said:


this is hardly profs intimidation

however you are stonewalling


what do you call someone refering to himself as a "pro" player and to others as "newbies" if not intimidation? modesty perhaps?

Proff is not shy on words, but he's also calculating. His sevral reference to high profile players being still alive and his little dance with linkz are both a way to probe players, to flater the ones he designates as "pro" and to intimidate the "newbies". It may be due to the lack of post in this game, but it stands out as exagerated to me this game.

and what do you mean by stonewalling?

not true it's a completely legitimate question. Why not kill the players that have shown time and again that they can figure things out eventually? This is a very serious question, and it troubles me that not only do you not see that yourself, but that you are trying to use it against me. To me, it only looks like you are intentionally ignoring the fact.

Hey if you're townie, I totaly understand your rebutal, but I took the position that you are scum today and so far I find the results of my position to be quite fruituitous (how the heck do you spell that word?). There is some warranting to your idea and perhaps it is just the low activity that makes it look pushed too much this time arround... still I believe that my interpretation is plausible and baal won't deny that I stired the bee nest here ^^



OoOoOoOoOoOoOoOoOoOoOoOoOoOoOoOoOoOoOoOoOoOoOoO

Linkzmax said:

Did you forget that your vote is on prof after already mentioning such within the post?

Otherwise, I'd say your making a great point. Wonk did say the same thing twice, but worded differently. More importantly the interaction between Wonk and you AND prof and you does lead me to believe there is some indirect connection between the two. However, I'm not convinced that the two of them are both mafia. Furthermore, I can't imagine I correctly have 2 of the 3 of you pegged as scum, so I'm worried that dsis and/or one of the lurkers is just sitting back and letting a majority of townies clash with each other.


you'll notice I dropped you from HoS to FoS in there, I reput the vote for the hierarchy.

and yes I fully agree that something is amiss in these connection, that is one of the reasons I think wonk is faking a connection with you.



OoOoOoOoOoOoOoOoOoOoOoOoOoOoOoOoOoOoOoOoOoOoOoO