By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

I dont really believe dsisters claims.   

The redirectors theory seems quite possible, and since dsister refuses to give anymore info

Vote: dsister



Around the Network
dsister said:

And again, redirector only targets/effects one person. Which would have been radish, since my power was only manipulating him, and not doing a thing to theprof.

Since the Watcher would of seen who targeted theprof only radish would of shown up. So me being a redirector isn't supported by Vetteman's night results


You would have had to targetted both parties. Target Radish for the ability and then target theprof for who it would go off on. The bus driver theory is impossible. We know who Vetteman, and you targetted. Your lies are not very convincing.



Starcraft 2 ID: Gnizmo 229

dsister said:


And if I was lying I would of come up with a better one. How was I to know that Radish would of targeted someone that had scanned innocent... And if I were to have successfully done that wouldn't I have had to known where Radish was going to target?


Radish had to strike randomly. You are a good enough player to know the odds are against him getting a good clean kill. He was essentially an extra serial killer for the night. Stopping a random night kill is always in the best interest of the town, and you know it.



Starcraft 2 ID: Gnizmo 229

I need some clarification, would the redirector appear as a visitor? I haven't played a game with redirector so can't tell from personal experience, and also can there be a combination of SK and investigation skill? I ask because the Prof's death appears in blue, taking it into account that radish supposedly visited prof, but the death seemed peculiar in a sense that he had an apparent bullet hole, which could indicate another SK - blue same colour as ABC's target.

It doesn't make sense that radish would target prof if he was a vigilante, after a person that he confirmed as town, identified prof as town.

This is very complicated, maybe hat can provide one of his insightful posts? Been awful quite lately.



Disconnect and self destruct, one bullet a time.

Gnizmo said:


Radish had to strike randomly. You are a good enough player to know the odds are against him getting a good clean kill. He was essentially an extra serial killer for the night. Stopping a random night kill is always in the best interest of the town, and you know it.


I thought he would be smart enough to stay away from the people confirmed innocent. We had a good little group of people that were out of any suspicioun. 

Besides those that perished and one or two others I couldn't possibly care about who he hit



Sig thanks to Saber! :D 

Around the Network

Vote Dsister

A redirector's action would show on both targets. 

Why would you block someone who didn't have a night action? Your claim does not make sense to me.



I am the black sheep     "of course I'm crazy, but that doesn't mean I'm wrong."-Robert Anton Wilson

Gnizmo said:


You would have had to targetted both parties. Target Radish for the ability and then target theprof for who it would go off on. The bus driver theory is impossible. We know who Vetteman, and you targetted. Your lies are not very convincing.


No no...

A watcher see who visits the person. With the role of redirector you would visit the person you target(aka radish) you do nothing to the person that you redirect the person to. The role of redirector has no effect on the person who is redirected upon. So you wouldn't appear at the person's house. 

The bus driver remark was just an example of how the watcher would work. Since his power is directly affecting two people he would appear to be at both their houses. 

@bolded: That is the only bit of truth in your post. You know who we both targeted. That is 



Sig thanks to Saber! :D 

NotStan said:

I need some clarification, would the redirector appear as a visitor? I haven't played a game with redirector so can't tell from personal experience, and also can there be a combination of SK and investigation skill? I ask because the Prof's death appears in blue, taking it into account that radish supposedly visited prof, but the death seemed peculiar in a sense that he had an apparent bullet hole, which could indicate another SK - blue same colour as ABC's target.

It doesn't make sense that radish would target prof if he was a vigilante, after a person that he confirmed as town, identified prof as town.

This is very complicated, maybe hat can provide one of his insightful posts? Been awful quite lately.


He would have to visit both much like the Bus Driver. One visit to gain control of a person, and one to target the person. Otherwise there would be no controlling who got hit. Besides that the role blocker theory smells fishier than a tuna factory.



Starcraft 2 ID: Gnizmo 229

dsister said:


No no...

A watcher see who visits the person. With the role of redirector you would visit the person you target(aka radish) you do nothing to the person that you redirect the person to. The role of redirector has no effect on the person who is redirected upon. So you wouldn't appear at the person's house.

The bus driver remark was just an example of how the watcher would work. Since his power is directly affecting two people he would appear to be at both their houses.

@bolded: That is the only bit of truth in your post. You know who we both targeted. That is 


Targeting someone is visiting them. That is how the whole affair works.



Starcraft 2 ID: Gnizmo 229

Gnizmo said:
NotStan said:

I need some clarification, would the redirector appear as a visitor? I haven't played a game with redirector so can't tell from personal experience, and also can there be a combination of SK and investigation skill? I ask because the Prof's death appears in blue, taking it into account that radish supposedly visited prof, but the death seemed peculiar in a sense that he had an apparent bullet hole, which could indicate another SK - blue same colour as ABC's target.

It doesn't make sense that radish would target prof if he was a vigilante, after a person that he confirmed as town, identified prof as town.

This is very complicated, maybe hat can provide one of his insightful posts? Been awful quite lately.


He would have to visit both much like the Bus Driver. One visit to gain control of a person, and one to target the person. Otherwise there would be no controlling who got hit. Besides that the role blocker theory smells fishier than a tuna factory.

I am thinking the same too. Both "half" role blockers being pro town is quitely unlikely, combine that with a confirmed half doctor, a cop, a vigilante cop and watcher, town seems seriously overpowered.



Disconnect and self destruct, one bullet a time.