By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - General - Truck Drivers Told They Need To Pay A Licensing Fee To Listen To Music While Driving

source

Over the last few years, we've noted that various collection societies around the globe have become both more aggressive and more ridiculous in trying to get people to pay licensing fees for listening to music. Among the crazy stories that have popped up are cases of collection societies demanding cash from a woman who played music for her horses in a stable, a police station told to pay up because some police officers had a radio on and the public entering the station could hear it, hotels being told they need to pay an extra performance license because guests listen to radios in their rooms and, of course, the claim that ringtones (even legally licensed ringtones) require another license as a public performance. In some cases, these societies apparently hire people to just call up businesses and if they hear music in the background, they demand payment.

Every time we post this kind of thing, people joke that it won't be long before they want to charge people a separate license for listening to music in your car with the windows rolled down. We haven't quite reached that point yet, but the Belgian collection society SABAM, who was recently caught accepting payments for made up bands, is now claiming that truck drivers listening to the radio need to pay a performance fee as well, since the cabs of their trucks are technically their "workplace."

This seems pretty extreme, even by traditionally insane collection society standards. Most of them admit that they only seek to collect fees in cases where the public might hear the music. Going after truck cabs seems beyond ridiculous -- and thankfully some in the Belgian Parliament seem to agree, with one MP saying, "it's utter nonsense." Still, SABAM seems to be standing by their right to collect in such cases, perhaps not realizing what an incredible laughingstock this makes them, and how it just makes people respect copyright less and less when such stories get out.

For tl;dr

They want money because the truck is a workplace...



Around the Network

Please tell me this is an April Fools article poking fun at Copyright Laws.... 



New headline

"Music Collectives Told They Need To Fuck Off"



I heard a similiar story in Vancouver. A guy owned a resteraunt and listened to a radio in the kitchen. Apparently it could be heard in the main dining area. A guy came in working for a collective agency and heard the music , he then proceeded to bill the guy for years of music because his resteraunt had been open for several years. The guys wanted something like 5,000$ in unpaid liscenses.

Until then I didn't even know that you weren't allowed to play music in a store or resteraunt without paying liscenses. If I open a store I'll just get one of my musically gifted friends to create some techno and some music to play. I'm not going to pay some collective fee for listening to the radio or letting my customers hear the radio.

I think its bull, the radio station already pays royaltees and liscensing fees. The public has access to that radio station for free on their car radio's or other radio devices. So why should a store pay for liscensing and royalties when the royalties and liscensing has already been paid by the radio station?

Also why is it free for people to listen to their radio's but not free for them to listen to radio's in buisnesses? I think its just one big cash grab, taking advantage of people!

Also why doesn't this pertain to sports bars or any bars, where they have the TV on? If you require a liscense for playing music in your buisness shouldn't you require one for video? I don't know if they do but many resteraunts and bars I go to have the tv's on. Also I go to the gym and can watch TV in their while I run.

Infact at the swimming pool they have Much Music on, so shouldn't they be paying music liscensing fees and then paying Much for playing the music , then pay their cable company to pay for the cable?

If you bill for everything where do you stop?



-JC7

"In God We Trust - In Games We Play " - Joel Reimer

 

Joelcool7 said:

If you bill for everything where do you stop?


When you go to jail and we start paying your bill in return :)



Around the Network
Rath said:

New headline

"Music Collectives Told They Need To Fuck Off"


this



PC gaming is better than console gaming. Always.     We are Anonymous, We are Legion    Kick-ass interview   Great Flash Series Here    Anime Ratings     Make and Play Please
Amazing discussion about being wrong
Official VGChartz Folding@Home Team #109453