You know, I MIGHT agree, but that was way before the existence of Nintendogs.  Now to me, a killer app is whatever the hell resonates with people, for whatever reason.  I guess we'll see.

This just in:

Oreo claims milk is the beverage it always wanted.

Also:

Green Bay Packers fans claim Super Bowl victory is what they always wanted.

this would have made sense if it was only them saying this

Isn't the OP about "Sony devs" only?

Yeah I'm just saying it has more cred to what they are saying because pretty much the whole industry has been saying the same thing..that's all

A killer app by definition is a peice of software that raises hardware sales substantailly. Anything that does not do that cannot be called a killer app.

Right now little deviants to me is in the same category as that sorcerer game for the ps3 move.  has a bunch of talk and people excited about what it showed.  but i'm in the waiting game and not going to call this a killer app or sysetem seller or hell even a game until later.

i mean where is sorcerer? 

until litte deviants and sorcerer get released they are just tech demo's in my eyes.  nothing more

Wii Sports has been out for five years and many people still consider it nothing but a glorified tech demo.  Didn't stop it from being the greatest killer app of this gen. 

Sorcery is one of the first ground up move games to use it in a cool looking way, hence the games hype.

Calling it a killer app isn't up to you, we will know when it comes out.

difference between wii sports (which i consider practically a tech demo as well) is that it was released and WE get to play it.

Does ANYONE have sorcerer?  Can ANYONE play sorcerer?  no, so it is just a tech demo showed at e3 as of now.  Just like steel diver was for the DS.

So basically your argument is we can't know the future?

We know that, this is obviously all about speculation and possibilities.  No one will know for sure until it comes out obviously.