By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - General - Three Israelis lynched on way to a pub

Rath on 07 November 2010
Kasz216 said:


1)  I'm not underestimating it... I said that SOME of the settlements should stay.   Likely the ones around Jersusalem, and the city itself.  When you fight over something and lose it's COMPLETELY asinine to expect to get back exactly what you would of gotten before the fight.  I'd like to see you argue that it isn't.

I mean, you don't think it's damaging at all to say "You can start a war and the only negatives would be you might lose... and then everything goes back to normal."

That's exactly what would of happened had Israel played it how the UN wanted them to.

2)  An occupied territory of what?  England?  The UN?

3)  They never have been punished for it.  If someone steals someones purse, and in purseing the officals falls down some steps and paralyze themselves... they still are tried and face a penalty and go to jail right?  Charges may be dropped if the victimized party agrees... but they don't.

It's not like the people deserve to be punished, but the nation that will be born deserves to be.  Fighting because you don't like a deal then demanding that the other side honour that deal when you... is just the epitome of stupid. 

4)  Palestinian's say Yes.  War never happens.   Palestinian's say no... war is inevitable.

1) Some of the settlements are bound to stay sadly, but land will have to be offered in exchange. Once again, even the Israelis don't really dispute that they will have to offer land for the land they are annexing.

2) Palestine. As I said, even the Israelis consider it occupied territory, they do not have a legitimate claim to it and they know it.

3) That analogy is just stupid. The Israelis are the ones who have imposed the conditions on the Palestinians ever since the 1967 war.

4) Are we even talking about the same war? I'm talking 1967 war, not 1948. The borders are never going to go back to the 1948 borders and nobody is arguing for that to happen.