By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Gaming - Playstation MOVE vs Xbox KINECT Lineup (see games below).

 

Playstation MOVE vs Xbox KINECT Lineup (see games below).

Playstation MOVE 234 75.24%
 
Xbox KINECT 77 24.76%
 
Total:311
Mr Puggsly said:
unknown_soul89 said:
Mr Puggsly said:

More so than the line up, I'm looking forward to MS's new technology as is everyone else.

Ultimately, the best games use a joystick.


How is it new, both the ps3 and wii have come out with a cam of some sort for some games, well wii is only one, the tech isn't new at all MS is just pretending it is and people like you are believing them 

Don't play dumb, you know the Kinect has far more capabilities than the Eyetoy.

You might wanna do some reading on it before you compare it to a webcam.

just copying this list in can't be bothered reading it. used in before when people call the eye a web cam. oh and it is funny Microsoft want to ignore there last adventure in using camera technology for games. xbox live vision. they were so boastful at the time.

ps eye:

augmented reality which includes, gender recognition, facial recognition, age recognition, object recognition (patented well everyday items are patented), facial expression recognition (patented well laughter is patented), head tracking
there is a mic but it's primary purpose was to help detect the position of the user, in my experience it isn't good at voice recognition, although that could be down to the software aswell,
movement detection

there is more I'm just not thinking of it at the moment. oh and most of the augmented stuff is from what sony says is in its vision library with the exception of eyepet very few games use them.

natal (based on what MS has told us)
augmented reality from what I have seen they also have a pretty descent library although they haven't demonstrated or shown age recognition. I don't see any reason why they can't do it though the facial expression and use of everyday items are patent protect so unless there is away round it. it includes gesture recognition.
3d depth tracking,
full body tracking,
mic, primarily designed as a command interface,
one step up from the eye's movement detection instead of using the pixels, alone to determine movement it will use two lenses and an IR sensor
area you have to be in will adjust depending on the size of the room.
built in processor to do the calculations, freeing up the 360, processor. (the chip is called prime sense made and named after the company behind the tech),
again there is more probably a lot more with natal but this is just of the top of my head.
 

this was before e3 2010 and I am to lazy to update it.



correct me if I am wrong
stop me if I am bias
I love a good civilised debate (but only if we can learn something).

 

Around the Network

just read about it in the official move thread. game called create from EA, its got move support but apparently no Kinect support and its multiplat

http://gamrconnect.vgchartz.com/post.php?id=3559003

oh just a question you have a total of 50 games, but yet when you add 28 1st party games with 20 3rd party games you get 48, is there some 2nd party or something?

edit: oh yeah just noticed 1 N/A one but what about the other



correct me if I am wrong
stop me if I am bias
I love a good civilised debate (but only if we can learn something).

 

30 of those games dont even require Move so therefore Kinect >>> Move

but look theres a suprise 112 votes in favour of Move and a measly 37 for Kinect .......is it just me or can anyone else smell fanboy denial?



move complete ownage



Eh, Ubi and Miz have given a repeated "no comment" on the possibility of both Move or 3D support for Child of Eden.  Right now, it's not officially a Move game and should be taken off the list.

There's also no official source for Harry Potter being Move compatible afaik?  And no, Wikipedia in itself isn't a source (and the article doesn't give citation for Move support anywhere).  Actually, it hasn't yet been confirmed for Kinect either, the only link there is a retailer leak (which was then retracted).



Around the Network
FF_Fanatic said:

move complete ownage


Kinect has more 3rd party support so far though, and for full priced retail games Kinect is competitive too.  Move killing it in numbers is due chiefly to (1) Sony's overwhelming support and (2) tons of PSN games and retrofits.  If you look at just 3rd party, or just retail, it's basically even numbers wise.



jarrod said:
FF_Fanatic said:

move complete ownage


Kinect has more 3rd party support so far though, and for full priced retail games Kinect is competitive too.  Move killing it in numbers is due chiefly to (1) Sony's overwhelming support and (2) tons of PSN games and retrofits.  If you look at just 3rd party, or just retail, it's basically even numbers wise.


lol you know what makes wii so special right, yes thats right it's the 1st party line up, but more and more devs keep on dropping kinect support, like it's latest vitim creat which is being done by, it really is looking bad forkinect now this is my list of games that kinect support has been dropped

john daly, ruse, mgs, rising, create, dead space 2 so thats move 5 kinect 0, and lets not start on quality of games because all kinect has now is eytoy -esque games, until 15-24 months time when kinect will track... wait for it the xbox controller sixaxis at $140- rip off



Mr Puggsly said:
unknown_soul89 said:
Mr Puggsly said:
unknown_soul89 said:
Mr Puggsly said:

More so than the line up, I'm looking forward to MS's new technology as is everyone else.

Ultimately, the best games use a joystick.


How is it new, both the ps3 and wii have come out with a cam of some sort for some games, well wii is only one, the tech isn't new at all MS is just pretending it is and people like you are believing them 

Don't play dumb, you know the Kinect has far more capabilities than the Eyetoy.

You might wanna do some reading on it before you compare it to a webcam.

Far is a stretch, I won't argue that kinect can do more then the ps eye but not alot more, and most of the stuff it can do that the ps eye can't do (or rather can't do as well) is pure software and has nothing to do with the tech MS is pretending is "new" basically the only things kinect is better at is depth perception and facial recognition I can't think of anything else, the eye can track the body it's been done (both in kung fu panda and in a vid I saw in a tech demo of move with it overlaying the guys limbs and tracking them with a skeletal thing over the vid, I'm unsure if the wands aided with this in anyway, it did not appear so) it's hard to say which is better at it without a back to back thing, so yeah, kinect an improve over the eye toy yes, a huge improvement, I don't really see it, the main dif seems to be hype and pushing the product 

Well the Eyetoy has been out for a long time now and a vast majority of the games involve you starting at yourself and smacking random objects. A few titles can understand some gestures and thats pretty much it.

So with that said, I think the Kinect is a huge improvment. It has far more potential and will get many games that can't be duplicated on the Eyetoy.

Just because the eye toy didn't reach it's potential doesn't mean that kinects potential is much higher lol, the eye toy wasn't supported because of the issues, where kinect they seem to be ignoring the issues and hoping people will do the same 



jarrod said:

Eh, Ubi and Miz have given a repeated "no comment" on the possibility of both Move or 3D support for Child of Eden.  Right now, it's not officially a Move game and should be taken off the list.

There's also no official source for Harry Potter being Move compatible afaik?  And no, Wikipedia in itself isn't a source (and the article doesn't give citation for Move support anywhere).  Actually, it hasn't yet been confirmed for Kinect either, the only link there is a retailer leak (which was then retracted).


I'll look into that. Thank



IrishCollie said:

30 of those games dont even require Move so therefore Kinect >>> Move

but look theres a suprise 112 votes in favour of Move and a measly 37 for Kinect .......is it just me or can anyone else smell fanboy denial?


What the hell are you talking about they both have about the same number of games that are motion control only (I think kinect has one more) and ps move has like 30 others that it's compatible with, alot of them that are multiplats and available on the 360 but don't have kinect support probably because the devs realize it won't work