No... Soleron in fact says to tanstalas in that post:

Voting No Lynch is not suspicious in itself.

What is, however, is subsequently adding nothing to the discussion; here are all of his posts:

"Nothing that makes any one seem guilty to me yet. Although this game did just start. For now...

Vote: No lynch"

--

dsister said:

So Mario any reason why you don't want to have any conversations today? Why the need to end the day so soon?

HoS: Supermario128

"I said "for now". As in, if somethign else happens I will change it. Don't over look things so much Dsister... At this point in the game nothing has happened."

--

dsister said:

Of course nothing has happened yet. Nobody is taking the initiative. Instead of just coming in here and voting why not ask questions?

"Because it is late and I am tired after a long day"

--

"My roles sucks too."

--

Which reads to me like: Vote No Lynch because it's safe; then switch off posting unless challenged.

I just noticed that he made a point of highlighting why supermario should be suspected, which would be odd to do to such an extent if he was on his team. Not that it's impossible that he's Mafia A group, just it seems unlikely to me. Of course he could be Mafia B... but I'm just making observations on what I see as I reread the thread.

Unvote Vetteman94

Vote Supermario128

I don't care anymore if he is town or scum. He did nothing to contribute the town, rather he hurt the town by hammering RCT. Maybe we would have got more information out of RCT. he has became an annoyance that we should remove. He should be lynched for being a serious pain in the butt.

So much bad playing in this game.

Silver-Tiger, supermario DID NOT hurt the town by hammering RCT and depriving us of the opportunity of getting info out of him. RCT was A MAFIA LEADER and would have NEVER given us anything helpful to the town. RCT was pretty much guaranteed a lynch, unless he had some tremendously stellar defense up his sleeve.

Rather, supermario prematurely ended the day before everyone could post their thoughts and contribute to any real discussion, which was bloody annoying indeed.

But I REALLY DON'T LIKE that you want to lynch supermario regardless of whether you think he's scum or not, effectively saying 'let's give the mafia a free shot at us if we must!' That is truly anti-town behaviour. I want this type of rationale to stop right here and now.

vote: Silver-Tiger

Regarless of my motivations, there are enough reasons to vote for Supermario. He's not interested in playing this game, and if our votes are enough to motivate him to finally play for real, we got what we wanted. For now, my vote will stay on Supermario128. If he decides to contribute something for the town, I will be the first to withdraw my vote.

Is that ok for you?

Isn't Transgent just the most pompous man you've ever met?


Anyway, I'm really torn now:
On one hand I think I should just vote Supermario because he's being so incredibly suspicious and doing nothing for the town. Also, unlike dsister, who was talking a lot initially; his crazy behaviour only started once people started to suspect him.

However on the other hand he's acting in such a care-free manner its hard to believe he's actually trying to hide something. Transgent also makes a valid point about Soleron, mafia members usually try to avoid talking about each other at all during the day let alone attacking them.

Possibly SM128 is a serial killer and didn't use his night ability on the first night because he wasn't about?
I'm still perplexed about how theRepublic died.

I going to give SM128 a chance to defend himself and perhaps roleclaim: but if its not convincing I see no other choice but to vote for him.

Really Nikells ? SM128 is either retarded, doesn't care about the game at all or is simply insane OR anti-town.....I think its either option 2,4 or 3.

It doesn't look like he wants to defend himself.

Edited mistake

I think its quite obvious that he was killed by a vigilante/SK

unvote

Vote:godofwar_3ever

Any particular reason why ? 

I can't explain it but I think you're scum. Plus you've already roleclaimed if i'm not mistaken so if you do turn out to be town then it won't be that big of a loss