Agreed, there's just too many ways Kinect can fail. And that 3DS thing in your sig is hillarious!

Wouldn't the adding controller Kinect defeat the whole purpose of "controller-free gaming"? I guess they're gonna have to in the future to get most core games to work. Halo Kinect Controller does sound cool I guess.

Just saw this on gaf.  They're in an uproar about it. 

I'm gonna wait for more information before jumping to conclusions.

Only one of those is of any concern and that is you have to be standing even for menu navigation.  Seems odd to me.

It's already tiring to "drive" for a long period of time with hands straight out. I would expect you could atleast sit down to relax. Not everyone is in shape like Billy Blanks.

Hmm... standing up? That sucks. Sorry, but it's true. Who will want to stand up the whole time they're playing a game, for every game? O_O

If this is true it surely is just a current bug.  After all they showed and people tried it last year around E3 while sitting playing Burnout.

M$ E3 adds have the person sat down doing navigation. So it will be in the final product. 

http://twitter.com/aarongreenberg

@hasanahmad @sixokay Yes you can sit or stand with Kinect, depends on the game or experience.