trangentspree said:
Final-Fan said:
Well, trangent's weighed in now, but I'm still unsatisfied. He talks a lot about dsister being weird and suspicious (which is true), and finishes by saying he's considering voting him, but without ever coming up with an objection to the current plan of waiting till tomorrow to see if he can prove his innocence. And he says that dsister's painted a big target on himself, which is also true, but wouldn't that be another reason to NOT lynch? Let the mafia do it for us?
FoS trangentspree.
|
Well you seem to have overlooked my earlier post this day?
I'm baffled by dsister actively drawing so much attention to himself - because it is exactly not what I would expect a player with the ability he suggests he has to do, in fact it's the type of behaviour I would expect a player not afraid of getting nightkilled to do. That post was more my trying to make sense of this whole situation and certain things that I thought might go wrong with this plan.
1. dsister has hinted quite strongly what his role/ability might be, and it might be enough for j0 to nullify him. Alternatively, this might play into an excuse for dsister tomorrow if he's been lying to us, to claim he got nothing because he lost his role. I'm not saying this is likely to happen, but I want the possibiliy that it could to be stated.
2. dsister is now a very noisy and obvious target. Just surviving the night would be inherently suspicious - unless there is more about his role that we do not know or other factors come into play. If he does survive, and this mod notification comes true it should hopefully be enough to dispell any concern about this. But he's either very confident in his security or he's made a complete and continued botched job out of today and he's hoping to get very lucky.
In my earlier post I looked at dsister, falcon and mario because they stood out as most suspicious to me. I only ruled out falcon in my last post because he had become a lot more active finally and because I thought he was making some decent points - I'm not against the plan for waiting until tomorrow with dsister but I at least want the opportunity of looking at the thread more thoroughly than I was able to last night before deciding if I think mario or anybody else is more deserving of my vote right now.
|
This is the post that made me suspicious of trangentspree.
His first point seems to me like he's suggesting that j0 removes dsister44's power (which would be convenient for him if he's scum) or alternatively he's giving dsister44 a way to get out of his promise (convenient for him and dsister if they're both scum, which I doubt but is still possible).
His second point, ignores the possibility of protective roles even though there was no night kill on Night 1. Also, it could be paranoia talking, but saying "dsister surviving the night would be suspicious" is the perfect setup if he's scum. He puts that idea out there and kills someone else during the night then brings it up tomorrow.
