By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - General Discussion - Mafia Round 16 - Brawlsville

^ wow you do not know how helpful that post was.

I can prove SFB is lying (again) because I know who Luigi is

Dude falcon seriously If I were scum tranj could have done a lot of damage with SFB abilities... come on think. Don't force me to say anything that will just hurt the town.



I am the black sheep     "of course I'm crazy, but that doesn't mean I'm wrong."-Robert Anton Wilson

Around the Network

also if I reveal who luigi is, I can prove that vetteman is up to no good as well because only scum would back off from calling sfb out.



I am the black sheep     "of course I'm crazy, but that doesn't mean I'm wrong."-Robert Anton Wilson

hatmoza said:
also if I reveal who luigi is, I can prove that vetteman is up to no good as well because only scum would back off from calling sfb out.

When did I back off from calling SFB out?  



^well I honestly do not know if you guys had any back and forths BUT if I reveal who the real Luigi is and prove that SFB is lying, that doesn't look good for you because if he lied about Luigi, he lied about kirby, and you didn't call him out for giving you a false role (unless he got super fucking lucky with you being Kirby)



I am the black sheep     "of course I'm crazy, but that doesn't mean I'm wrong."-Robert Anton Wilson

hatmoza said:

^well I honestly do not know if you guys had any back and forths BUT if I reveal who the real Luigi is and prove that SFB is lying, that doesn't look good for you because if he lied about Luigi, he lied about kirby, and you didn't call him out for giving you a false role (unless he got super fucking lucky with you being Kirby

Well what exactly is his title again?   The Spying Primid, is it?  Is it possible that he has the ability to see who someone is, hence the spying part in his name.  There is probably good reasons as to why when he looked at therepublic, he saw Luigi,  we had a bus driver in this game for one.  



Around the Network

theRepublic posted awhile ago thinking that Vette, SFB or TOS were his top 3 suspects, I thought at the time I agree'd with him, however, went back and looked at a couple other posts from before and found this one:

 

SuperAdrianK said:

I'm back! (best day of my life ever.)
Anyways, I found vetteamn suspicious since he assumes dsister is lying when there is always a chance he is innocent (I started to lean over him that he is innocent t=with the speculation you guys made).
How are you so sure he is lying, and why lynch him today?

Of course, this is just my opinion...

HoS: Vetteman

I could change my vote... but I would like to hear your response first.

 

We all know SAK was scum now, so I think this post probably rules Vette out of contention for being scum as I don't think SAK would throw a fellow subspace buddy under the bus so soon..

I could be wrong about that and could be a tactic I suppose point the finger at a scum buddy and have him defend himself so that he looks innocent and if he ever goes out then you look innocent as you fingered him..  (I'm still very new to this)

Even if we mislynched SFB today (think he just needs 1 more vote) and subspace took one of us out tonight it would still be 5 townies to 2 subspace (if we are assuming correctly that we started with 3 mafia) and if we lynch SFB and he turns out to be pro-town then I would say that Vette is probably pro-town as well, unless he is an evil Kirby :)

If SFB turns out to be scum then I would say we look a little closer at Vette - as we know for a fact that SFB was already lying, or at least incorrect on who theRepublic was



Unicorns ARE real - They are just fat, grey and called Rhinos



All I got from j0 is tranj controlled SFB and scoped "X" and found out he was Luigi. X does not = TheRepublic.

The busdriver theory can explain why he knows theres a Luigi in the game (out of all the brawlers, I don't think it's coincidence that he got Luigi results just like I did)

bleh that makes too much sense.


I am the black sheep     "of course I'm crazy, but that doesn't mean I'm wrong."-Robert Anton Wilson

Tanstalas said:

theRepublic posted awhile ago thinking that Vette, SFB or TOS were his top 3 suspects, I thought at the time I agree'd with him, however, went back and looked at a couple other posts from before and found this one:

 

SuperAdrianK said:

I'm back! (best day of my life ever.)
Anyways, I found vetteamn suspicious since he assumes dsister is lying when there is always a chance he is innocent (I started to lean over him that he is innocent t=with the speculation you guys made).
How are you so sure he is lying, and why lynch him today?

Of course, this is just my opinion...

HoS: Vetteman

I could change my vote... but I would like to hear your response first.

 

We all know SAK was scum now, so I think this post probably rules Vette out of contention for being scum as I don't think SAK would throw a fellow subspace buddy under the bus so soon..

I could be wrong about that and could be a tactic I suppose point the finger at a scum buddy and have him defend himself so that he looks innocent and if he ever goes out then you look innocent as you fingered him..  (I'm still very new to this)

Even if we mislynched SFB today (think he just needs 1 more vote) and subspace took one of us out tonight it would still be 5 townies to 2 subspace (if we are assuming correctly that we started with 3 mafia) and if we lynch SFB and he turns out to be pro-town then I would say that Vette is probably pro-town as well, unless he is an evil Kirby :)

If SFB turns out to be scum then I would say we look a little closer at Vette - as we know for a fact that SFB was already lying, or at least incorrect on who theRepublic was

oh don't worry SFB is scum. His role is equal to a "Mafia Cop" 

or at least thats how I understand it.



I am the black sheep     "of course I'm crazy, but that doesn't mean I'm wrong."-Robert Anton Wilson

@Falcon - I would be interested in seeing what you have to say now... I think Hatmoza has explained as much as he possibly can, even though it has been confusing as heck as to what he told us vs what Trangent said earlier..



Unicorns ARE real - They are just fat, grey and called Rhinos

Vetteman94 said:
hatmoza said:

^well I honestly do not know if you guys had any back and forths BUT if I reveal who the real Luigi is and prove that SFB is lying, that doesn't look good for you because if he lied about Luigi, he lied about kirby, and you didn't call him out for giving you a false role (unless he got super fucking lucky with you being Kirby

Well what exactly is his title again?   The Spying Primid, is it?  Is it possible that he has the ability to see who someone is, hence the spying part in his name.  There is probably good reasons as to why when he looked at therepublic, he saw Luigi,  we had a bus driver in this game for one.  

I'm trying to understand this as well, if SFB and Hatmoza are both telling the truth than why did Hatmoza get Luigi = X (not theRepublic) and SFB got theRepublic as Luigi?

If there was a bus driver type character and both Hat and SFB are telling the truth than wouldn't they both see theRepublic as Luigi? 

Since Hatmoza is saying when he used SFB's skill he saw who Luigi was I am going to assume it maybe worked like this:

a)SFB targets theRepublic to see who he is
b)Trangent targets SFB and assumes control of his ability
c)Trangent then retargets someone else with SFB's ability say TOS
d)since SFB is just expecting a name back he sees 'Luigi' when really Luigi is really TOS 

I assume that is how it worked, in which case, SFB wouldn't really be lying about who he saw, so in that case, if we Lynch SFB and he is pro-town I'd say Vette is pretty much guaranteed to be pro-town, in which case he'd probably be a target at night.  If SFB was scum then I'd say that Vette is probably scum as well.



Unicorns ARE real - They are just fat, grey and called Rhinos