By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - General - Smoked's Pixar Feature-Length Animated Film tier.

voty2000 on 12 April 2010

Wall-E and Cars are my favorites followed by UP.



Around the Network
okr on 12 April 2010

My Top 3:
Monsters Inc. (one of the best animation movies I've ever seen with one of the most surprising plot ideas)
Toy Story
Toy Story 2 (best animation movie sequel ever imo)

I have seen all other Pixar movies except Up - which is a shame as I already bought the BluRay/DVD-Combo months ago.

I love all Pixar movies I've seen except Cars and Wall-E.

Cars' plot and humor are too simple for my taste (similar to 20th Century Fox' awful, but very popular Ice Age movies - horrible copies of the trademarked Disney formula imo).

I really wanted to like Wall-E, but there's something about this movie I don't like. Maybe the overall emptiness or the feeling that Pixar wanted to achieve Miyazaki's level of storytelling - I don't know.

The world's 2nd best animation studio at the moment.



Boutros on 12 April 2010
okr said:
My Top 3:
Monsters Inc. (one of the best animation movies I've ever seen with one of the most surprising plot ideas)
Toy Story
Toy Story 2 (best animation movie sequel ever imo)

I have seen all other Pixar movies except Up - which is a shame as I already bought the BluRay/DVD-Combo months ago.

I love all Pixar movies I've seen except Cars and Wall-E.

Cars' plot and humor are too simple for my taste (similar to 20th Century Fox' awful, but very popular Ice Age movies - horrible copies of the trademarked Disney formula imo).

I really wanted to like Wall-E, but there's something about this movie I don't like. Maybe the overall emptiness or the feeling that Pixar wanted to achieve Miyazaki's level of storytelling - I don't know.

The world's 2nd best animation studio at the moment.

Behind Studio Ghibli?



CommonMan on 12 April 2010

To me, Up and The Incredibles are two of the best all around movies I've ever seen. After that's they are pretty equally great, but those are transcendant.



No one in the world ever gets what they want, and that is beautiful.

okr on 12 April 2010
Boutros said:
okr said:
My Top 3:
Monsters Inc. (one of the best animation movies I've ever seen with one of the most surprising plot ideas)
Toy Story
Toy Story 2 (best animation movie sequel ever imo)

I have seen all other Pixar movies except Up - which is a shame as I already bought the BluRay/DVD-Combo months ago.

I love all Pixar movies I've seen except Cars and Wall-E.

Cars' plot and humor are too simple for my taste (similar to 20th Century Fox' awful, but very popular Ice Age movies - horrible copies of the trademarked Disney formula imo).

I really wanted to like Wall-E, but there's something about this movie I don't like. Maybe the overall emptiness or the feeling that Pixar wanted to achieve Miyazaki's level of storytelling - I don't know.

The world's 2nd best animation studio at the moment.

Behind Studio Ghibli?

Exactly.



Around the Network
Orca_Azure on 12 April 2010

up should be in the top tier. It holds the title of the only move to have ever made me cry -.- i wasn't ready for that kind of stuff in a pixar movie man. I just wasnt' ready



SmokedHostage on 12 April 2010

A) Ocra_Azure, your new avatar is awesome.

B) Bottom Tier doesn't mean you're a bad movie. You're just the worst among the others.

C) No Monty, I'm not doing a Disney film thread anytime soon.

D) I'm loving the responses, keep 'em coming.



Pixel Art can be fun.

nordlead on 12 April 2010

Top Tier

Toy Story
Finding Nemo
Toy Story 2
Monster's Inc
The Incredibles
Wall-E

Mid Tier

Cars
Ratatouille
Up

Low Tier

A Bug's Life

however, pretty much everything pixar makes is gold. Oh, they aren't really in "order" other than being in the right tier.




If you drop a PS3 right on top of a Wii, it would definitely defeat it. Not so sure about the Xbox360. - mancandy
In the past we played games. In the future we watch games. - Forest-Spirit
11/03/09 Desposit: Mod Bribery (RolStoppable)  vg$ 500.00
06/03/09 Purchase: Moderator Privilege  vg$ -50,000.00

Nordlead Jr. Photo/Video Gallery!!! (Video Added 4/19/10)

SmokedHostage on 12 April 2010

Nobody loves A Bug's Life. ;__;



Pixel Art can be fun.

okr on 12 April 2010

While I didn't enjoy Wall-E as much as I hoped, the special edition of this movie contains my most favourite DVD special ever: The Pixar Story - a nearly 90 min. running documentary.

http://www.imdb.com/title/tt1059955/
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=C70Yp3CPvuQ
(This trailer doesn't really do the documentary justice - it's not one of those typical boring special features where everyone finds everyone else great; actually it's one of the most interesting and revealing company documentaries I've ever seen. Highly recommended).