By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - General Discussion - Mafia Round 15B - Game Thread

nordlead said:
dsister44 said:

So basically what Nordlead is trying to say is that you'll be lynched for:

  • Talking too much 
  • Lurking too much

And also 

  • Agreeing with someone
  • Not agreeing with someone 
  • Not paying attention to people's post
  • Not be online when people get bored 
  • Being annoying
  • Trying to save someone

As long as you don't do any of this stuff you'll be fine

I didn't say that you get lynched for talking to much. I can't say I've ever been lynched that I can remember, but I've been night killed a lot. I've come close to getting lynched

I've been lynched for talking too much =/

Though that might fall under the "being annoying" one 



Around the Network

Supermario and the 'Mama Mia!' incident

I've attempted to construct a summary of everyone's actions regarding Mario yesterday, to help search for his fellow humans. I probably included too much here, but I tried to keep things relevant and brief. Call in if you think I misrepresented your posts.

What I draw from this

  1. At some point, sooner or later, to a lesser or greater extent, Mario's fellow humans sold him out to the town.
  2. J0 and SuperAK were the most reluctant to lynch Mario. j0 dithered a lot and SuperAK just didn't want to see him lynched.
  3. I very, very much doubt that Final-Fan is human.
  4. Nordlead abruptly voted for Mario after a lot of people had voiced their suspicions, and the more the day went on the more Mario seemed to give up on the game.
  5. I  doubt that j0 and Nordlead could both be human.

So my suspicions land in this order

SuperAK

j0

Nordlead

 



Now to backtrack on what's happened today...



nordlead said:
well, I'll start the day off with some FoS's

tangentspree, j0, & dsister better explain why they didn't vote for the human.

Because I voted for you. Perhaps not one but two humans managed to attract suspicion on Day1?

I'd also like to point out that when I voted I had the opportunity to save Mario if I voted 'no lynch', but that I didn't.



TruckOSaurus said:

Here's a post from trangentspree right after my HoS on supermario.

trangentspree said:

Also SuperAdrianK

Now that you're here, do you think Truck used rather lazy logic to cast HoS against supermario?

We can see here that trangentspree quickly tried to dismiss the suspicions on supermario by calling my logic hazy, trying to discredit the fact that SM128 could have indeed slipped up.

HoS: trangentspree

Final-Fan made something of a decent case as to why I should be regarded with suspicion, but this is ridiculous.

You ignore the fact that I threw around a shitload of questions yesterday, and a lot of them had to do with drawing out opinions on what people had to say about Mario's slip up.

I'll say this: I don't like people hiding during the daytime. If something relevant happens during the day, I want to hear everyone's voice on the matter so I can judge where everyone is coming from. What I don't like to see are people skirting topics with joke-posts or by just ignoring what everyone else is talking about. Yesterday I didn't just want to see Mario steamrolled over, and hope for the best that he turned out to be human - I wanted to generate conversation about different topics so that we wouldn't go into Day2 with nothing to talk about in the event that he wasn't human.

And yes, I do think your logic for HoS Mario was pretty lazy. Not that I didn't think he deserved suspicion.



Around the Network
trangentspree said:

What I draw from this

  1. Nordlead abruptly voted for Mario after a lot of people had voiced their suspicions, and the more the day went on the more Mario seemed to give up on the game.

lol, what do you want me to do. FoS him all day long and wait for someone else to vote first? It wasn't abrupt at all, I just took the first step. I can't help it most of the town are too cautious (almost always the case with "let's wait..." or "I don't want a mislynch")

Because I voted for you. Perhaps not one but two humans managed to attract suspicion on Day1?

I'd also like to point out that when I voted I had the opportunity to save Mario if I voted 'no lynch', but that I didn't.

If you want to use that as proof that you aren't human, then why do you ignore the fact that I started it in the first place which is a much stronger indicator that I'm not human. No one even voted for mario until over 25 posts after I did. Then people slowly piled on.

However, after scanning the votes there were no times where no-lynch was at L-1. In fact, when you voted the voting was as so

supermario128 - nordlead, TruckOSaurus, Falcon095 (L-2)
nordlead - Final-Fan (L-4)
No Lynch - supermario128, SuperAdrianK, c03n3nj0 (L-2)

Not voting - dsister44, trangentspree

With 9 alive, 5 votes are required to lynch.

(table will be posted at the start of each day)




If you drop a PS3 right on top of a Wii, it would definitely defeat it. Not so sure about the Xbox360. - mancandy
In the past we played games. In the future we watch games. - Forest-Spirit
11/03/09 Desposit: Mod Bribery (RolStoppable)  vg$ 500.00
06/03/09 Purchase: Moderator Privilege  vg$ -50,000.00

Nordlead Jr. Photo/Video Gallery!!! (Video Added 4/19/10)

lol, what do you want me to do. FoS him all day long and wait for someone else to vote first? It wasn't abrupt at all, I just took the first step. I can't help it most of the town are too cautious (almost always the case with "let's wait..." or "I don't want a mislynch")

You had made two posts prior to your vote, one of them was a joke post. I call that pretty abrupt. Of course you may just be an impatient Day1 player, or maybe you are a human that saw an inevitable lynch and decided to cut your loses early in an attempt to come out smelling of zombie flesh.

However, after scanning the votes there were no times where no-lynch was at L-1. In fact, when you voted the voting was as so

l was the final player to vote as it seemed that dsister wasn't planning to do so. So why wouldn't WoW bring the day to an end going with the majority vote? Unless themed games are different to regular games in this respect?



trangentspree said:
lol, what do you want me to do. FoS him all day long and wait for someone else to vote first? It wasn't abrupt at all, I just took the first step. I can't help it most of the town are too cautious (almost always the case with "let's wait..." or "I don't want a mislynch")

You had made two posts prior to your vote, one of them was a joke post. I call that pretty abrupt. Of course you may just be an impatient Day1 player, or maybe you are a human that saw an inevitable lynch and decided to cut your loses early in an attempt to come out smelling of zombie flesh.

However, after scanning the votes there were no times where no-lynch was at L-1. In fact, when you voted the voting was as so

l was the final player to vote as it seemed that dsister wasn't planning to do so. So why wouldn't WoW bring the day to an end going with the majority vote? Unless themed games are different to regular games in this respect?

I clarified why I voted. If a human says "I'm human" there is no reason to wait. If a zombie says "I'm human" then I have no problem punishing poor play. Besides the fact that there really wasn't much to discuss there at all.

Also, the day doesn't end until a majority is reached, WoW decides to end the day due to it moving nowhere or some deadline is reached with no conclusion. I've never seen a day ninjastriked dead just because everyone voted and no conclusion has been made yet. (unless there has been a change to how things work on this forum in the last game)

 




If you drop a PS3 right on top of a Wii, it would definitely defeat it. Not so sure about the Xbox360. - mancandy
In the past we played games. In the future we watch games. - Forest-Spirit
11/03/09 Desposit: Mod Bribery (RolStoppable)  vg$ 500.00
06/03/09 Purchase: Moderator Privilege  vg$ -50,000.00

Nordlead Jr. Photo/Video Gallery!!! (Video Added 4/19/10)

Bumping for vote count on next page.



Bump once more..