Alan Wake

Alan Wake :D

Splinter Cell for me because I'm a long time fan of the franchise.

Alan Wake

Ι'd rather cut a foot finger than choose one of these two babies...

Never had the patience to really get into Sam's exploits so another vote for Wake. Sales might not be as one-sided as you think. Alan Wake isn't taking the kind of chances HR was and without PC competition it could do a couple million LT.

perhaps its because i been a fan of the splinter cell series that i pick splinter cell if i were to choose,

but my decision is also base on re playability which i know splinter cell will deliver.

Splinter Cell. I don't even want Alan Wake.

Splinter Cell. Alan Wake... looks like the new Alone in the Dark, seriously. Not graphically, but gameplay wise, I feel like I've already "played" this game before.

I am going with Alan Wake, such an amazing looking and feeling game. But SC:C should have more replay value do to the inclusion of multi player...Unless Alan Wake has multi player....lol