| ktchong said: When Edge gave a 7 to Mass Effect, Xbox fanboys certainly did not whine and complain like Sony fanboys are with Heavy Rain. |
I'm not sure how true that is. I remember plenty of people moaning about it.
Is EDGE Magasine | |||
| Biased towards the XBOX | 130 | 46.26% | |
| Biased towards the PS3 | 35 | 12.46% | |
| Biased towards the Wii | 12 | 4.27% | |
| A fair and honest reviewer | 104 | 37.01% | |
| Total: | 281 | ||
| ktchong said: When Edge gave a 7 to Mass Effect, Xbox fanboys certainly did not whine and complain like Sony fanboys are with Heavy Rain. |
I'm not sure how true that is. I remember plenty of people moaning about it.
I remember when Edge gave Killzone 2 a 7/10 and "Lets tap" for Wii a 8/10 at the same time.
They are biased against the PS3 , funny how many people cant see it. (or just dont want to)
Fedor Emelianenko - Greatest Fighter and most humble man to ever walk the earth:
| ProdigyBam said: I remember when Edge gave Killzone 2 a 7/10 and "Lets tap" for Wii a 8/10 at the same time. They are biased against the PS3 , funny how many people cant see it. (or just dont want to) |
Yeah. That is definitely odd.
| ProdigyBam said: I remember when Edge gave Killzone 2 a 7/10 and "Lets tap" for Wii a 8/10 at the same time. They are biased against the PS3 , funny how many people cant see it. (or just dont want to) |
The Let's Tap review is up there with the worst reviews they've ever printed, only one mode in that game was any good, and that was only good for an evening or two in multiplayer - even if the race mode had been released as a stand-alone downloadable title for 500 points, gamers would have been right to feel short changed. Poor show by Edge with the 8. But having said that, they weren't reviewing a £44.99 system seller, they were reviewing a £19.99 party game - not quite baragin basement territory, but as cheap as a store release gets. The score was way off where it should have been, but you can't compare budget game scores to those awarded to blockbusters, otherwise every XBL/PSN/VC title awarded a 7 of above could be moaned about in reference to Killzone 2. It doesn't work like that - otherwise a fun, throwaway 800 point downloadable title like Alien Hominid, weighing in at a couple of hour's play, would automatically have to reveive a mid-range score in concession to reviews for everything-but-the-kitchen sink epics.
Biased or not, they are misinforming their PS3 readers. The thing about reviewers is that they have the power to sell a game. Edge is being unfair to a lot of PS3 games, imo. I don't care either way. Reviewers are trash (yes, ALL of them).
I have an opinion on the OPs opinion on the opinion of EDGE towards PS3 games.
Luckily for everyone else I wont make thread about it.







