I haven't played ME2 yet, but if the core the game is the same as ME1, I really don't find myself liking it all that much. (and from all accounts it is)

On the other hand, my eldest brother absolutely loved Mass Effect.

So using that evidence, this clearly proves that Erik Brudvig is a wanker.

I have yet to play either so I will reserve my vote for which one is better until I do so.  But ME2 does look like it will be GOTY for 2010,  the only other games that could possibly recon with it are God of War 3, and Halo: Reach (there are probably 1 or 2 more but I can't think of them)

UC2 is overrated IMO.I played it, the story is ok but the MP is awful. The graphics are not "Only possible on PS3" type, its just colorful thats it.

@Carl

"If you like something your a fanboy, if you dislike something your a troll"

See? It's not just Nintendo. IGN overall has gone off the deep end. They're baiting their audience and they know it.

Uncharted 2 multiplayer horrible?

...

No.

Its not that i dont beleive you its just its only Feb and you are writing in green

Yes.

It sucks, you lose money for leaving, its impossible to aim the game, the AK has accuracy like a MG42 on a treadmill.

Maybe...

But it's fun! Isn't that what matters?

Anyone that's actually read the entire article knows that it is a perfectly reasonable and I feel accurate position to take. Certainly it is fully justified by the poster.

Incidentally, anyone that knows that poster's history knows they are not biased AGAINST the Ps3.

Thats not fun.