Well i've never seen Griffin make the same comments about Singstar so I'm guessing no.

RolStoppable  "From what I've read, Matt says that he has played it for three hours. I guess it would be pretty bad on his part, if he would write a review of an important game like this one and at the same admit that he hardly played it."

True, I guess I didn't really think of that.  Though it seems so far he doesn't want to play it more LOL.

An instrument is just a "noisemaker" if you randomly pound on it. They mustn't have any depth either.

After watching that video, it's kind of ridiculous a gaming journalist would put up a video of himself intentionally messing up a song just to make the game look bad. Goodbye integrity. I'll be waiting for his video in the Rock Band 2 preview where he purposely misses all the notes.

Matt's never liked the game. He's kind of biased against it right off the bat. I want to see what Game Trailers has to say about it.

Now its finally happened, the hardly core media now trying to stop the Wii momentum.

Because they know there number is up. The mainstream media now getting into gaming. People who actually went to writing school or learned about real journalism are finally going to replace our overweight, basement dwelling, dorrito stained journalists we have now. Games are going to be reviewed and based on FUN.

And it is glorious.

I lost all repect for IGN and their opinions when they started making up rumors all the time that turn out to be complete horsecrap.

Kid Icarus @ E3
Kingdom Hearts @ TGS etc....

I usually like IGN reviews , but this shows that some people there should really think about what Journalism is.

What was the lowest rated 5 million seller before this? =P

I have to say I'm having a hard time seing the point of this game. That presentation by JC rodrigo only made it worse. It seems you can't even miss notes in this game. I might as well just tap my knee. I play a couple of instruments myself and I'm wondering how this can make anyone "feel the music".

That being said, maybe it's just not for me.