Edit: There are one or two Sony games that definitely deserve it. It just hasn't happened yet.
I don't expect it to happen this gen, either. There are more critics and publications than ever before and it's difficult to please everyone. The Last of Us Part II and God of War should score well, if their pedigree is any indication, but the focus on cinematic storytelling can be polarizing. Uncharted 4 suffered from lower-than-average scores based on being an "interactive movie" and for treating the player as a "passive...participant."