a interesting review-topic. metacritic say: Metal Gear Solid 5 has 93 % of all reviews worldwide. The PS4 exclusiv-game Bloodborne has 92 % ! That is AMAZING too. If you had to choose - What game is better for you personally / MGS5 or Bloodborne? I'm curious about your thoughts :) (but please no spoiler)

update: Its officall now. Fallout 4 has between 87-89 %. So, Metal Gear Solid 5 > Bloodborne > Fallout 4. BUT: All 3 games are big and awesome^^ the Game of the Year is clear now, i think. This year was very interesting :)

MGS 5

http://www.metacritic.com/game/playstation-4/metal-gear-solid-v-the-phantom-pain/critic-reviews

Bloodborne

http://www.metacritic.com/game/playstation-4/bloodborne/critic-reviews

Bloodborne.

MGSV is a massive disappointment to me as a MGS fan. It's not a bad experience (it's actually quite good), but it doesn't feel like MGS. I value the aspects that the game shred over those that it adopted. I really feel that critically MGSV was reviewed in a bubble (due to the Nazi camps) and we're seeing divisive thoughts by gamers themselves.

There are more games to be released this year. Including xenoblade chronicles X

I liked MGS V but the last missions in the game are stupid. Redoing old missions with certain conditions suck.

Bloodborne was absolutely brilliant though. I give it my vote.

There is still time to see if Xenoblade Chronicles X takes the spot but for now... Bloodborne wins.

I'd personally consider TW3 (92), Bloodborne (92), and MGS5 (93) tied. General variance makes that 1 point difference functionally meaningless.

It's also worth noting that 2015 isn't actually over yet :p There are still quite a few games coming out this year that could score well, such as Tomb Raider, Fallout 4, Legacy of the Void, Star Wars: Battlefront, Just Cause 3, Rainbow Six Siege, and XCX.

Bloodborne
While the original Xenoblade was the best game last gen, I see this one underperforming from a quality standpoint.  Can't see it getting above an 87.

maybe idk. What quality standpoint do you mean?

From reviews of the Japanese version I heard the plot is really weak, the pacing is bad and the characters are boring.  Music is subjective, but I'm sure you've heard the battle theme.  Probably not a bad game, but dissapointing compared to XC.

I'm just waiting for Fallout 4 and XCX before making conclusions.

I´m a Metal Gear fan (or...used to be) but MGSV left a bad taste, the core gameplay is the best the series has ever seen but everything else is a disappointment.

What a disappointing swan song for the Kojima Metal Gear games.