By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Gaming - Apple in legal trouble over free-to-play apps

 

Who is right here in this instance?

Apple 13 25.49%
 
Plaintiffs 32 62.75%
 
Neither 1 1.96%
 
Else 1 1.96%
 
See results 4 7.84%
 
Total:51
SnakeDrake said:
Whats the point of a 15 min window anyways

It could reasonably be argued that it's for convenience, that one could buy several products in a specific timeframe without having to continuously enter a password, but it's up to the courts to decide these things. Undoubtably, the evidence will be comprised of how much apple profits from f2p purchases, the contractual obligations they haev to the developers, and some kind of scientific proof that argues for the existence of a 15 minute window, say, studies that show most purchases happen at the same time in a single sitting, or buying window.

The lawsuit will likely be upheld. iOS has been a known feeding ground for these f2p apps that target kids, and apple has not done its responsibility in protecting its customers. For example, a 15-minute window is all well and good...when it's at the discretion of the user. The existence of it as a default (if there were an option) is risky.

I think the payout will likely be judged based on how much of an infraction it is. If it was a simple oversight, or argued to be so, plaintiffs might get full refunds plus damages resulting from them (overdraft fees, etc). If it's judged that the decision was a business one, it could be a lot worse.



Around the Network

What parents should / shouldn't do has no bearing on the vileness of predatory marketing practices like this. The knowledge that a lot of parents are slack when it comes to these things should not be a licence to make money off poor parenting skills. Parents need to be protected (or at least not made to suffer excessively) from their own stupidity, not exploited because of it.



“The fundamental cause of the trouble is that in the modern world the stupid are cocksure while the intelligent are full of doubt.” - Bertrand Russell

"When the power of love overcomes the love of power, the world will know peace."

Jimi Hendrix

 

TWRoO said:
This is very much Apple's fault... reasonable levels of security should be the default, a 15 minute window is dumb. I mean if you leave your house, but it takes 15 minutes till your door is locked that would be ridiculous. Yes in cases like these there is always some blame to be put on the parents, but the main portion of the blame rests on whoever decided that 15 minute window.

This seems to summarize the point neatly enough.



Monster Hunter: pissing me off since 2010.