By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close
Wyrdness on 27 September 2019
Edit Thread
Hiku said:

I know that's what you said. But you did not state that you believe reviewers "do not take into account" content that was added in a previous version.

Why would they not take these things into account? Because they, or the readers, may have experienced these before?
If that's the case they would would not take into account any content that was experienced in any prior version.

Nier: Automata port for Xbox One:

Story: Same story again. So can't take that into account. 0/100
Graphics: Same. 0/100
Gameplay: Same. 0/100
Music: Same. 0/100

If anything, some outlets are debating if they should go back and renew certain reviews again after a while, because of these kind of updates. As these days some games significantly evolve after release, or are not complete on release.
The reasoning I've heard against doing this is because it wouldn't be worth the effort, as most people who would read the review or buy the game already have.

What are you even on about? Are you even reading what you're replying to? The first line about not taking into account content that was added is the complete opposite of what I posted as if you read my post you'd see I flat out said they took new content and changes into account that's the whole point this reply tells me you didn't know what I said at all you've just tried to read between lines that aren't there with your reply.

Side by side the new elements in DQXI S aren't in the other version that factors into the score, XV doesn't have that situation it was more of a GOTY type deal.

Last edited by Wyrdness - on 27 September 2019