| Best Shooter |
Winner: Gears of War 4
Runner-up: Bioshock Collection |
| Best Platformer |
Winner: ReCore
Runner-up: FRU |
| Best Sports/Racing |
Winner: Forza Horizon 3
Runner-up: FIFA17 |
| Best RPG |
Winner: ...
Runner-up: ... |
| Best Action-Adventure |
Winner: Quantum Break
Runner-up: Dishonored 2 |
| Best Horror |
Winner: Oxenfree
Runner-up: ... |
| Best Singleplayer Campaign |
Winner: Quantum Break
Runner-up: Gears of War 4 |
| Best Multiplayer |
Winner: Gears of War 4
Runner-up: ... |
| Best Narrative |
Winner: Quantum Break
Runner-up: Oxenfree |
| Best Graphics |
Winner: Gears of War 4
Runner-up: Forza Horizon 3 |
| Best Art Design |
Winner: Dishonored 2
Runner-up: Quantum Break
|
| Best Soundtrack (music) |
Winner: Dishonored 2
Runner-up: Virginia
|
| Best Sound Design (effects/voices) |
Winner: Quantum Break
Runner-up: Gears of War 4 |
| Best Performance by a Male Actor |
Winner: John Dimaggio as Marcus Fenix :)
Runner-up: Aidan Gillen as Paul Serene |
| Best Performance by a Female Actress |
Winner: Erin Yvette as Alex (Oxenfree)
Runner-up: Courtney Hope as Beth Wilder |
| Best Free To Play Game |
Winner: ...
Runner-up: ... |
| Best ID@Xbox Game (indie) |
Winner: Oxenfree
Runner-up: The Little Acre |
| Best DLC |
Winner: The Witcher 3 Blood & Wine
Runner-up: Forza 3 Blizzard Mountain |
| Best Console Exclusive |
Winner: Forza Horizon 3
Runner-up: Gears of War 4 |
| Best Xbox One Games With Gold Release |
Winner: Sunset Overdrive
Runner-up: ... |
| Best Xbox 360 Games With Gold Release |
Winner: ...
Runner-up: ... |
| Best Backwards Compatibility Release |
Winner: Alan Wake
Runner-up: Red Dead Redemption |
| Overall Xbox Game of the Year |
Winner: Gears of War 4
Runner-up: Forza Horizon 3 |
