BB was probably voted by the staff and the other articles were written by a editor and associate editor who have their own opinions.
To be fair, I would have picked the witcher over BB.
agree with you on that one.
Still Bloodborne was my third favorite game of the year and can see why it would get the nod and I mean it's not like they chose Her Story.
This is the Game of Thrones
Where you either win
or you DIE