Wow, we sure have some rabid OoT fans.

[SuperLloyd]

ckmlb said:

luinil said:
The whole argument is that OoT was called "the perfect game" and has aged very well. Ppl simply don't want a game that isn't perfect to supplant a perfect game. If a game is worthy then it should be placed at #1, but if it does have issues, then can it be called #1?

No game is perfect. OoT has aged well in your opinion, I disagree. I think Zelda: TP can completely replace it now and you wouldn't lose anything. On the other hand, Mario 64 has aged much better.

That's actually not true at all. The Past/Future dual world scenario would not be replicated and thus produces two very different games. While the SNES Zelda started the dual world scenario, Twilight Princess's is decidedly different in execution and not integral to the overall adventure like OoT's.