| theprof00 said:
You're so flustered you can't even read what is written. I said you can add ME being a hypocrite to your list of poor accusations. I wasn't vague in the slightest. You asked me why I thought something and I gave you an answer. If you want a more in depth analysis of why, then ask for that. Three team thing? I'm talking about there being three sidekicks, and DT talking about why suspicion against those players simply for being their characters was laughable, as he said in so many words. Vig has nothing to do with DT. What I'm telling you is that scum WANT to draw attention to the meta of three sidekicks with one hero because it is always a good scum stance to lean on things what make town paranoid and question the meta of the game, EVIDENCED by the fact that one of them was killed. In no way did I link or say DT had anything to do with the meta. What I did point out was that DT, as scum, should indulge in the meta because it is advantageous for scum to do, as EVINDENCED by the fact that it made (imo) a townie kill another townie. Period. I didn't say your suspicion had anything to do with me being in line. I said your suspicion is lacking in foundation because I said in that very post that I was too cold to look things up. I think you just wanted to point something out to show that you were contributing, but that was the wrong post to pick out. Like I said, had you commented that the reads seemed a bit flimsy, I'd be fine, and explaining them to you, but since you eagerly jumped on it by calling me scum (HAHA without explaining your reasoning, making me ask for an explanation...funny. That is exactly what you're accusing me of) I don't think you'd thought it through. You're starting to make my brain hurt. ABC and Radish have done NOTHING but talk meta. You're starting to sound like you're trying to force a non-existant point. DT has done way more than talk about meta. 1 He has early day 1 jokiness. 2 "What it has done is shown me which players are willing to create suspicion on people over nothing. For that reason FoS: ABC FoS: Spurge FoS: DanneSandin Jumping on a nontell is textbook Scum behaviour. " Disparaging players who are talking meta, using a very real and applicable scumtell.
A very valid argument. Trucks said 'why not me', dt answered reasonably.
Again, very valid point. Flavor hunting does work, but the instance was one where it clearly was not appropriate.
This was also something I had been pondering. So I appreciate that DT is thinking along the same lines that I am. Indeed there could be a very simple explanation for the way the characters are. The fault is in thinking that pezus did everything perfectly, which is what others have been doing. Blaming the mod is a VERY EASY way to mislynch.
Again, a very reasonable post that is quite right. And I also suspect yoshiya.
Asking questions of other players for their reasoning. So, I see you tend to leave out your reasonings for scumspects more than just once.
I'm sorry but I could do this all day. Nothing here says scum, and everything says townie playing his town self. |
I leave out my reasoning for obvious reasons, and it always works out. Look at j0 for instance in that MLP game. I left my reasoning to attack him the next day, he was scum and he was caught.
I am not asking someone why they think someone is scum or town - so I am not a hypocrite.
His post towards zero - what you call as reasonable, is just not. I don't see how that statistic is anything reasonable.
HIm trying to figure out why I suspect him - seriously? SO let me guess. J0 never tried to figure that out - nope he did. Carl never tried to figure it out in his game either, oh wait nope. He tried to do it too.
So yeah, stupid observation on your part.
________
As far as your beginning of the post is concerned -
You were being vague, but I normally don't care about it. You were the person who were upset that someone was vague. In fact, I am surprised you were this upset I thought you were scum.
You are using "what scum would probably do" way too much. Reminds me of Linkz in the Random Videogame Characters Round.
Attacking people who are discussing meta/flavor is also something I've seen scum do. Did you see DT metaing last game? Nope. And yet he was scum.
The people who were actually talking flavor were the likes of mario(poisoner), zero(town), yourself(lol), and maybe a couple of others. The scum team - tabaha, DT, spurge, did NOT talk meta/flavor much, if at all. SO much for your "Scum would try and talk meta" argument.
You were not the subject. There was no need for me to talk about you, your suspicions or anything. You came into suspect list because of your suspect list, and there is no reasoning required for that to happen.
You think my suspicion is lacking in foundation; yet you aren't even referencing what makes me suspicious of you. Like I said, it has got nothing to do with your lack of justification for your reads. Which is weak anyway, now that you've provided them.
Except for one part where he FOS's three people for metaing, which was at the beginning of the day, nothing screams town like you suggest, and a lot of them actually led to me to be suspicious of him.
