You can't argue that my theory COULDN'T happen. That is why it is logical.
You can argue that my theory DIDN'T happen. With which I will submit that I don't know any more than anyone else.
The entire thing was brought up because the question arose, by a 360 fan *rolls eyes that you didn't read this* that why is it ok for 360 to have so much in supply and not ps3. I brought up a logical reason as to HOW it could be possible. Nothing more. Don't get too excited.
So because something might be true, it's a valid argument?
You can apply that to everything with gleeful ignorance of all established fact. It could be utterly ridiculous, but you can do it. For example, there might be a race of mutant sheep living on the moon plotting our demise. You can't prove it wrong because it might be true.