Mafia Round 36 - Suikoden II

[theprof00]

spurgeonryan said:

theprof00 said:
After thinking very hard about the matter, I'm not sure that discussing cop candidates is very beneficial to town.
And I'm leaning toward it being actually detrimental.
Perhaps more discussion on the subject is necessary.

You want more cop canidate discussion? Whats your game Prof? i am not sure you are really that interested. If you are then your actions  sound like something a mafia member would do. But you are an experienced player so I do not think you would just make a comment like that on accident.

 

Ruse.   Mafia. Square one.

Perhaps I was unclear.

The last sentence is supposed to read "perhaps we should discuss whether or not to discuss night votes". I'm both against discussing night votes, and slightly for it. I'm for it because it keeps the choice with the majority. I'm against it because that person who we think should be copped will be a death sentence (if they are town). See, mafia will want to kill anyone who is copped, especially on the night it happens, thereby making the investigation useless.  This also means that doc will have to choose between the majority agreed player and someone else, which means mafia could have free reign to kill anyone in town.

I think that's a bad scenario. I don't see how it's good for town at all. But, it's not my decision to make and therefore, we should discuss whether we should talk about candidates or not.